7

If one is staying away from large gatherings for medical reasons (eg. due to the risk posed by COVID-19) or if one's shul is closed (perhaps for the same reason), how might one satisfy the requirement (based on Devarim 25) to hear Parshas Zachor before Purim? Read it oneself, from a chumash? Silently or out loud? Other?

  • The Rabbanut Harashit in Israel is apparently discussing this and other issues right now. – Harel13 Mar 4 at 16:04
  • I think that some of the talk around here recommended a reading on Purim instead of shabbos, and that megillah might be acceptable via phone, so one wonders if Zachor could also be possible by phone. – rosends Mar 4 at 16:30
8

The Rama 685:7 writes that one should still read it with its correct tune.

הגה: ואם אי אפשר להם לבוא, מכל מקום יזהרו לקרותם בנגינתם ובטעמם (מצא כתוב).

The Kaf Hachaim 685:35 writes one should read from Sefer Torah preferably(without bracha),but if one doesn't have ,a chumash should be used.

לה) שם הגה. ואם א"א להם לבא מ"מ יזהרו לקרותם וכו' ר"ל אם יש להם יקראו אותם בס"ת אלא בלא ברכה כגין שאין מנין ואם אין להם ס"ת יקראו אותם בחומש של דפוס:

| improve this answer | |
  • Aloud? With trope? Why no bracha? – Yehuda W Mar 4 at 16:26
  • 2
    Not sure what aloud means ,you should say the words,and the trup should be used as quoted in answer,no bracha is made on Torah without a minyan ,its a davar sbekedusha – sam Mar 4 at 16:27

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .