3

Generally speaking, when people think about fasting in terms of Torah, they are thinking about the type of fasting associated to the 9th of Av or Yom Kippur, meaning neither eating nor drinking. This is related to the idea of rising above the physical/material plane of existence.

In the context of a one day fast, or even a two day fast, that is possible, but is also a severe strain on the body.

However, in the context of making a tikkun over past transgressions, the number of fasts prescribed in Torah is often many more days than simply a day or two. See for example the references in the Tanya in Igeret HaTeshuvah at the end of chapter 1 to Sefer Rokeach and Mishnat Chassidim and also in chapter 3 there.

Medically speaking, fasting, meaning abstinence from eating, is something that can be done for many, many days consecutively. The longest consecutive fast from eating on record is over a year. While a total fast, abstinence from both eating and drinking can only be survived three to five days. The abstinence from water is the critical factor.

Does the Torah make a distinction between types of fasts? The Aramaic word for fast is תענית from the Hebrew ענה. The Hebrew root has a connotation of to respond or to answer (as in answering for improper actions) and also to deprive, or to delay, or to submit/become humble or to become poor. All of these relate to the idea of depriving oneself of food in humility and an act of submission to G-d's will.

The consequence being that one burns their excess body fat, which is compared to burning the fat of an offering on the altar brought in the Temple, like is mentioned in the Tanya for example.

So the focus seems to be about the burning of body fat, which relates to the eating of food only.

  • 3
    Where does the Torah prescribe fasts for more than a day or two? – Alex Oct 28 '19 at 17:25
  • @Alex Per your request... – Yaacov Deane Oct 28 '19 at 18:46
  • I feel you dig deep but couldn't understand the question. The only Taanit from Torah is Y"K which is commanded as תענו את נפשתיכם hence תענית, nothing to do with answer. So what "types" you're talking about? You HAVE to make a clear distinction between the Torah and any of its interpretations, especially very recent ones. – Al Berko Oct 28 '19 at 19:07
  • 1
    @Yaacov Most Jews indeed hold the book of Esther is not part of the Torah. – Double AA Oct 28 '19 at 21:22
  • 2
    @AlBerko It's Berakhot 17 ועכשיו ישבתי בתענית ונתמעט חלבי ודמי – Double AA Oct 29 '19 at 10:59
0

If I understand the question correctly, you are asking if there is a concept of fasting from food without refraining from water in Torah.

I would suggest that a צום could be refraining only from food but allowing water. In Ester 5:16 and Yona 3:5-7 not eating and not drinking are specified, which would seem to imply that there could be a tzom not like that. Also in Shmuel II chapter 12, Dovid is tzome, and only food is mentioned, not drink.

This is not conclusive; please don't complain about that.

| improve this answer | |
  • Not complaining & thanks for trying. Fasting is refraining from eating and drinking (food-something you benefit from). But ‘benefit’ in Torah has a particular meaning. This is discussed in Shulchan Aruch and elsewhere. That’s why we make blessings on pleasant scents too. Torah considers them to be a kind of spiritual food (less material than for example, bread and wine). And water, which has neither taste nor scent, is in a unique category. No surprise that Torah, at least part of it, is compared to water. – Yaacov Deane Nov 26 '19 at 22:59

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .