1

There are many countries with corrupted governments who steal taxpayers' money. Is one still obliged to pay taxes if the government is corrupted and steals a big fraction of the taxes one pays? What's the point of paying taxes if tax revenue gets stolen anyway?

  • Governments don't steal, don't oppress, don't discriminate, don't sin, etc - people do. So as long as the gvm governs and controls the order in the country, it is completely legit as DD"M. – Al Berko Oct 24 at 12:09
0

Rav Hershel Schacter wrote a nice piece on this very topic. In short, he explains that in the times of the Talmud the king would collect a tax. If the tax would be unfair than dina dimalchusa would not apply. However, nowadays we don't look at taxes the same as the times of the Talmud. Rather we view each neighborhood as partners and the taxes go towards the "partnership" of the neighborhood. These taxes pay for , police, fire, garbage, and so on. Most of taxes go to things that people need and want. However, if you would live in a place where a tax is taken in a very apparent unfair manner, then per the Shulchan Aruch it isn't Dina demalchulsa anymore.

Article link:

https://www.torahweb.org/torah/special/2005/rsch_taxes.html

  • 1
    All you do to address the question is to say that it "might be a question". This doesn't seem like an answer to me. – msh210 Oct 23 at 21:17
  • Is that how you read the answer ?! Its pashut that in a normal country where they provide services using tax money then one cannot say it's unfair. However, in a country where the taxes are unfair then one would not have to pay like the talmud and SA,the reason I ssy it may be a question is because I do not know what country he has in mind . – sam Oct 23 at 21:34
  • I don't know what country he has in mind either, but I'm pretty sure any place today where you can live openly as a Jew isn't corrupt enough for that Sh"A to apply. – Heshy Oct 23 at 22:30

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .