1

How Many vav Hahipuchs (Conversive vav) are in each of the 24 books of Tenach compared with the number of letters / verses in that book. As far as I know they are only in Tenach rather than Mishna or any subsequent work. It would be interesting to see if the number of conversive vavs declines as prophecy declined in the 2nd Temple period. I'd like to compare the ratio of conversive vavs in each book with the number of letters and verses in that book.

  • 2
    Goodness - too many to count, I'd venture. Can you describe a bit more about your motive for knowing this, or is it just a mere curiosity? – DanF Oct 13 at 4:43
  • The Vav hahipuch only appears on Tenach. I'm wondering if it is linked to nevuah. If so, it's use may have declined as the power of prophecy waned. – AlHal Oct 13 at 9:46
  • If there are less instances in post Bavel book, that would be evidence for my suggestion. Similarly, if there are more vav hahipuchs in Chumash than Nach that would also be evidence. – AlHal Oct 13 at 16:18
  • I had heard that one of the reasons for using vav hipuch is to convey the concept that time is both continuous and connected. I.e., the past is connected to the future and the future connected to the past. If you notice, in Hebrew verb conjugation, the present tense is "simplified" - there is no separate format for 1st 2nd and 3rd person; just singular and plural. Also, there is no present tense form of the word haya - "to be" / is / am. This is all within the concept that there is no true "present" time where time stands still. There's only past and future. – DanF Oct 13 at 20:22
  • Thanks for that insight. – AlHal Oct 15 at 21:12
1

I don't have a count, but I can give some rules about its appearance, and from that we can make an estimation.

In narrative portions, the vast majority of verbs introduced with a vav (which is most verbs) use the vav hahipuch. (This includes the beginning of verses, chapters, books, even the first word of the Prophets at the beginning of Yehoshua.) Also in commandments the vav hahipuch is used with the same frequency.

Spoken statements tend to have more verbs without the vav hahipuch, even when those verbs are introduced with a vav. (But it is used in quotations as well, for example Bereshis 3:10.)

The books of Tehilim, Mishlei, Iyov (other than the narritive at the beginning and end, and the introductions to the speeches) Shir Hashirim, Koheles and Eicha rarely use the vav hahipuch. (However, those books also don't have many verbs with a vav introducing them at all. There are instances of vav hahipuch in each of them, but you have to search for it.)

The vav hahipuch is used in the books of Ezra and Daniel as much as in other books. It is not used in biblical Aramaic.

With this in mind, let us estimate how frequently the vav hahiputo is used in each book:

1-9) In Chumash and Neviim Reshonim, the average usage is for sure more than once per verse.

10-13) In Neviim Achronim there are more prophetic passages, and fewer verbs introduced with a vav. Let us guess that this averages out to one for every two or three verses.

14-16) The poetic books of Tehilim, Mishlei, and Iyov have very few vav hahipuchs in total.

17-21) Of the five megilos, two of them, Ruth and Ester, have more than one per verse, and the other three have very few.

22-24) Ezra/Nechemia, Daniel and Divrei Hayomim all have fewer vav hahipuchs, the first two because of the Aramaic portions, and Divrei Hayomim (like Ezra) because of long genealogical passages. Let's put the average at one for three verses.

So, as you can see, most of the books with very few vav hahipuchs are from the early First Temple period (or earlier, depending on when Iyov was written,) and Eicha is from the Exile period. The more prophetic books use the vav hahipuch less than the less prophetic books, on the whole. And the books from the Second Temple period use the vav hahipuch almost as much as the earlier books.

  • כי הוא אמר ויהי – Heshy Nov 26 at 20:50
  • 1
    This seems like an extended comment. I'm not sure it answers the question. – Double AA Nov 27 at 1:46

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .