1

I gathered a couple of questions together because they might be linked but I'm OK with splitting them:

Why didn't Levi send a spy?

I know, I know they didn't have Nahalah in Israel. So what?

  1. The two and a half tribes didn't receive Nahalah in Israel but Moses obligated them to participate in conquering.

  2. As Leviim replaced Bchorot that surely had Nahalah in Israel, it appears that by the time of sending the spies Leviim did have the right of Nahalah. The decree of withholding Levi from Nahalah was introduced by Moses 40 years later right before entering Israel (Dvorim 18,1).

  3. Yehoshua did send Pinchas with Kaleb as spies (see the Haftarah)

Did Leviim cry with the rest of the people?

Leviim seemed a righteous tribe, but I didn't hear of them standing up against the crying as they did in the Golden Calf. Didn't they and why?

Why weren't Leviim exempt from keeping the 9th of Av?

If they were righteous, as usual, and didn't participate in the big cry, why weren't they exempt from keeping the 9th of Av Halochos. Like in "ידינו לא שפכו את הדם הזה".

See also this answer.

  • 1
    Levi’im would still be chayav on tisha be’av- the 2 B”H we’re destroyed for them too. – Lo ani Jun 23 at 10:54
  • 1
    The 2.5 tribes hadn't yet been assigned the other side of the valely – Double AA Jun 23 at 11:13
2

I Reuven and Gad did not request the land on the east of the yarden until after it had been conquered. See Matos 32:2 which has them asking Moshe and Elazar Hacohen (after the death of Aharon in the fortieth year). In any case, they were still considered as having received a nachalah with the others as it had been conquered and made part of the land.

The descendants of Gad and the descendants of Reuben came, and they spoke to Moses and to Eleazar the kohen and to the princes of the community, saying,

II The Leviyim had replaced the bechorim immediately after the sin of the Golden Calf. By the time of the spies, the Mishkan had been built, Aharon had become the Kohen Gadol, and the Leviyim had been assigned to the work of the Mishkan. Note that in the census of Bamidbar 1:1 the Leviim were already not counted to get land and be in the army. They were counted separately in order to work in the Mishkan.

III The spies sent in Shlach 13:2 were sent as the equivalent of a congressional junket with important men of the tribes. Each of them was sent as a representative of his tribe.

"Send out for yourself men who will scout the Land of Canaan, which I am giving to the children of Israel. You shall send one man each for his father's tribe; each one shall be a chieftain in their midst."

Rav Hirsch translates this as

"every one a prominent one among them"

On the other hand, Yehoshua sent Pinchas and Calev as actually spies on a secret mission. They were the equivalent of a Mossad team and were sent to report back to Yehoshua himself as the Bnai Yisrael were going to go no matter what.

IV The crying was done in the privacy of the tents of the individual tribes. As a result, there was nothing that the Leviim could have done. This is similar to the way that the Leviim could not rise up against the golden calf until after Moshe Rabbeinu had returned.

V Since the punishment of the 40 years in the midbar was applied to everyone, no matter whether they took part in the rebellion or not, then the Leviim also mourned on Tish'a B'Av. Also, this day is set up as the mourning day for all the things that have occurred to use throughout our history.

We see that even though the women did not receive the punishment of death during the next 38 years, they still mourn.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .