1

Rabeinu Yonah discusses one of the ways of repentance as leaving a little food over after the meal.

אך בעת מאכלו ועודנו תאב לאכול יניח ממנו לכבוד הבורא מתאוותיו, ואל יאכל כפי תאוותו. ודרך זה ימנענו מחטוא, ויזכרנו אהבת הבורא יותר מתענית אחד בשבוע. כי זה בכל יום תמיד מדי אכלו ומדי שתייתו יניח מתאוותו לכבוד הבורא

It seems to me the context he intended was a meal where one would save the food for a later date. My question regards how this practice could be observed in a situation where one could not save the food. Perhaps one receives stipend food in a context where saving is not an option. (Office, army, hospital etc.) wWould Rabeinu Yonah then rather wasting of food or fulfilling this edict? Or perhaps only to fulfill it when saving is an option - what if it never becomes an option (and I am too weak to fast, but I want to overcome my desires of food etc.)?

  • I like this question. In terms of philosophy, perhaps Rabbeinu Yonah considers that one should eat only for the purposes of preserving his health and no more. I.e., the sole purpose of eating is not for food enjoyment or to fulfill one's cravings. Thus, once one has done this, the rest is not considered "food" and if one cannot save it, as it is not "food", perhaps there is no concern about wasting it. In short, "food" is considered that only when it is needed for health purposes i.e. to satisfy one's hunger, not to overindulge. (Compare w/ Rambam's philosophy which is similar. Not surprising) – DanF May 30 at 19:50
  • 1
    Is this citation in Sha'rei Teshuva? You may want to edit the source in and perhaps provide a link. – DanF May 30 at 19:51
  • It’s it the יסוד התשובה (commonly, but not limited to, printed in the Yom Kippur machzor) – Dr. Shmuel May 30 at 19:54
  • 1
    Even if the food cannot be saved it's not wasteful as its being used to prevent him from sinning. – Jay May 30 at 23:32
3

Rabbeinu Yonah is not recommending we waste food. He is recommending we utilize some of each meal to practice self-restraint. Developing our ability to say "no" to a physical desire is no less important of a usage than consuming food to sustain our bodies and keep on living. After all, if we are weak in the ability to control such desires (taavos), how often will we make the wrong decision when having to choose between physical pleasure and doing the wrong thing?

1

The Gemora in Eiruvin 53b mentions this practice of leaving food at the corner of the plate for the shamash (attender) to eat his portion (also see Shulchan Aruch OC 170,3):

אמר רבי יהושע בן חנניה...פעם אחת נתארחתי אצל אכסניא אחת עשתה לי פולין ביום ראשון אכלתים ולא שיירתי מהן כלום שנייה ולא שיירתי מהן כלום ביום שלישי הקדיחתן במלח כיון שטעמתי משכתי ידי מהן אמרה לי רבי מפני מה אינך סועד אמרתי לה כבר סעדתי מבעוד יום אמרה לי היה לך למשוך ידיך מן הפת אמרה לי רבי שמא לא הנחת פאה בראשונים ולא כך אמרו חכמים אין משיירין פאה באילפס אבל משיירין פאה בקערה

So usually the attendant would eat the leftovers in those days (though nowadays with all our Abundence thank G-d people no longer need to rely on such rations and every attendant has their own private portion), and there was no issue of bal tashchis wasting food. To the contrary giving food to the more deprived.

But if there wasn't any buttler available or if the buttler didn't want to eat leftovers that day, then Rabeinu Yonah is saying to keep the practice leaving food on the side and not to finish it just because its there,as people are used to giving themselves larger portions than they need for the benefit of the attendant. On these occassion it is quite clear that one would try save food for later, or when perishable find someone else to give leftovers to as the whole Minhag stems from giving the leftovers to others.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .