7

Shalom everyone, I'm just curious, if a Jewish man is dating a woman who is converting I assume it wouldn't be appropriate to serve on her beis din, but is it prohibited halachically?

  • 1
    Welcome to MiYodeya Israel and thanks for this first question. Can I recommend you take the tour to get a sense of how the site works? Great to have you learn with us! – mbloch May 1 at 6:20
  • 6
    Someone dating a non Jew is probably categorized as 'a sinner' and hence invalid as a witness/judge. At least in 99% of cases. – Double AA May 1 at 12:09
  • @DoubleAA : What sin is someone committing when dating (without sexual contact) a potential convert? – user9806 May 1 at 17:32
  • 1
    @user9806 Possibly none. Probably many. – Double AA May 1 at 17:39
  • See the 3 last Mishnayot in the second chapter of Yevamot – kouty May 2 at 19:42
3

Mishna Yevamot 2.10

מיאנה או שחלצה בפניו יישאנה מפני שהוא בית דין

The context of this end of chapter is that a man who is the cause of the permission to marry of a woman cannot marry her because of suspicion. People will say he was not objective as witness or as expert to cancel her vow, because he intended to marry her.

But if he was a part of a bet din, there is no problem because we have no reason to think that the other dayanim did help him making a sin. It's not plausible that two dayanim did make a sin because of one. The Tosfot Yom Tov quoted this statement from the Rif who himself quoted it from Yerushalmi.

The case of the question is worst. But bediavad, it seems that by the logic of the Yerushalmi it's valid because he was not alone.

We need to explore a possible possibility of shochad. Shulchan Aruch CM 9.2. rules that shochad devarim bediavad doesn't disqualifie a judge. Since this woman didn't give him a gift to judge her able to convert there is obviously no more (if there is) than shochad devarim.

If he was dating this woman before her conversion and marry her afterward this leads people to think that she converted because she wanted to marry him. But even if it was the case the Gemara Yevamot 24a (SA EH 11.5) ruled that the conversion is correct. So why is said in Mishna that if people was saying he has a relationship with a non Jewish woman he cannot marry her Lechatehilla? Gemara answers because of a recommendation in Mishle to avoid to provoke the rumor.

  • +1 You must mention this is why Boaz was allowed to marry Rus. He AND HIS BEIS DIN ruled Amoni and not Amonis ... – user6591 May 2 at 22:16
  • 1
    @user6591 can you explain or give me a source regarding Boaz and Rut? – kouty May 3 at 1:54

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .