1

Is there any source in encouraging a man who identifies as Jewish but isn't so Halachically, to marry a Jewish woman and raise a Jewish family?

For instance, a patrilineal Jew although he isn't Jewish, if he is a cultural Jew and wishes to continue his Jewish family's legacy should he still be disuaded from marrying a non-religious Jewish woman? Is there a religious duty or source to have Jewish children?

Note: I ask because I am aware that a convert who is patrilineally Jewish has a slightly different status to a regular convert as he has the status of 'זרע ישראל' and is considered “מקרב אחיך" according the Aruch haShulchan in Choshen Mishpat 7:1.

15

The man isn't Jewish in this case, so he has no obligation whatsoever in marrying a Jewish woman. It is forbidden for the Jewish woman to marry this man because he is not a Jew. If the man truly feels a connection with Judaism he should convert.

3

Regardless of how he considers himself, he is not Jewish. Subsequently, it is not just not encouraged, but forbidden for him to marry a Jewess.

  • 3
    Which prohibition is that for him? – Double AA Mar 26 at 12:09
  • @DoubleAA kosby bas tzur for example (to avoid baal peor issues) – user15253 Mar 26 at 13:07
  • 1
    @Orangesandlemons judaism.stackexchange.com/q/43388 – Y     e     z Mar 26 at 13:55
  • 1
    @Y e z nice find, and according to those mefarshim it looks like it wouldn't be forbidden as such. However, it's perhaps worth mentioning that I'm fairly confident that when G-d tells someone 'don't do x' and someone actively encourages someone to do x, they are effectively setting themselves against Hashem and is forbidden misvarah even if not a direct 'mitzvah'. – user15253 Mar 26 at 14:24

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .