Skip to main content
Notice removed Authoritative reference needed by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with mbloch's answer chosen by CommunityBot
edited body; edited title
Source Link
mbloch
  • 54.1k
  • 10
  • 98
  • 257

What criteria determine what is or isntisn't Uvdin Dechol

I am struggling to understand the concept of Uvdin Dechol, where it originates from and how far it extends to.

We famously dont ride bikes / electric trams on Shabbos partly due to Uvdin Dechol, but many Poskim allow Shabbos lifts, which would seem should also be cateogrisedcategorised as Uvdin Dechol.

Even stranger was when I just saw the Magen AvrhohomAvrohom when discussing playing chess on Shabbos, that they used to play with silver pieces so as not to appear like Uvdin Dechol.

I am ideally looking for a thesis that someone has published with guidelines, sources etc clearly defining what it or isntisn't Uvdin Dechol.

If no such publication is out there, and you have knowledge to share on this, please share all sourceable information that you have.

What criteria determine what is or isnt Uvdin Dechol

I am struggling to understand the concept of Uvdin Dechol, where it originates from and how far it extends to.

We famously dont ride bikes / electric trams on Shabbos partly due to Uvdin Dechol, but many Poskim allow Shabbos lifts, which would seem should also be cateogrised as Uvdin Dechol.

Even stranger was when I just saw the Magen Avrhohom when discussing playing chess on Shabbos, that they used to play with silver pieces so as not to appear like Uvdin Dechol.

I am ideally looking for a thesis that someone has published with guidelines, sources etc clearly defining what it or isnt Uvdin Dechol.

If no such publication is out there, and you have knowledge to share on this, please share all sourceable information that you have.

What criteria determine what is or isn't Uvdin Dechol

I am struggling to understand the concept of Uvdin Dechol, where it originates from and how far it extends to.

We famously dont ride bikes / electric trams on Shabbos partly due to Uvdin Dechol, but many Poskim allow Shabbos lifts, which would seem should also be categorised as Uvdin Dechol.

Even stranger was when I just saw the Magen Avrohom when discussing playing chess on Shabbos, that they used to play with silver pieces so as not to appear like Uvdin Dechol.

I am ideally looking for a thesis that someone has published with guidelines, sources etc clearly defining what it or isn't Uvdin Dechol.

If no such publication is out there, and you have knowledge to share on this, please share all sourceable information that you have.

Notice added Authoritative reference needed by Yehuda
Bounty Started worth 250 reputation by Yehuda
Tweeted twitter.com/StackJudaism/status/1048226555888107521
edited body
Source Link
Yehuda
  • 6.1k
  • 22
  • 52

I am struggling to understand the concept of Uvdin Dechol, where it originates from and how far it extends to.

We famously dont ride bikes / electric trams on Shabbos partly due to Uvdin Dechol, but many Poskim allow Shabbos lifts, which would seem should also be cateogrised as Uvdin Dechol.

Even stranger was when I just saw the Magen Avrhohom when discussing playing chess on Shabbos, that they used to play with silver pieces so as not to appear like Uvdin Dechol.

IamI am ideally looking for a thesis that someone has published with guidelines, sources etc clearly defining what it or isnt Uvdin Dechol.

If notno such publication is out there, and you have knowledge to share on this, please share all sourceable information that you have.

I am struggling to understand the concept of Uvdin Dechol, where it originates from and how far it extends to.

We famously dont ride bikes / electric trams on Shabbos partly due to Uvdin Dechol, but many Poskim allow Shabbos lifts, which would seem should also be cateogrised as Uvdin Dechol.

Even stranger was when I just saw the Magen Avrhohom when discussing playing chess on Shabbos, that they used to play with silver pieces so as not to appear like Uvdin Dechol.

Iam ideally looking for a thesis that someone has published with guidelines, sources etc clearly defining what it or isnt Uvdin Dechol.

If not such publication is out there, and you have knowledge to share on this, please share all sourceable information that you have.

I am struggling to understand the concept of Uvdin Dechol, where it originates from and how far it extends to.

We famously dont ride bikes / electric trams on Shabbos partly due to Uvdin Dechol, but many Poskim allow Shabbos lifts, which would seem should also be cateogrised as Uvdin Dechol.

Even stranger was when I just saw the Magen Avrhohom when discussing playing chess on Shabbos, that they used to play with silver pieces so as not to appear like Uvdin Dechol.

I am ideally looking for a thesis that someone has published with guidelines, sources etc clearly defining what it or isnt Uvdin Dechol.

If no such publication is out there, and you have knowledge to share on this, please share all sourceable information that you have.

Source Link
Yehuda
  • 6.1k
  • 22
  • 52

What criteria determine what is or isnt Uvdin Dechol

I am struggling to understand the concept of Uvdin Dechol, where it originates from and how far it extends to.

We famously dont ride bikes / electric trams on Shabbos partly due to Uvdin Dechol, but many Poskim allow Shabbos lifts, which would seem should also be cateogrised as Uvdin Dechol.

Even stranger was when I just saw the Magen Avrhohom when discussing playing chess on Shabbos, that they used to play with silver pieces so as not to appear like Uvdin Dechol.

Iam ideally looking for a thesis that someone has published with guidelines, sources etc clearly defining what it or isnt Uvdin Dechol.

If not such publication is out there, and you have knowledge to share on this, please share all sourceable information that you have.