3 deleted 56 characters in body
source | link

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Between the two sefarim called ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor - One written by Rav Yisrael Al-NakawehRav Yisrael ben Yoseph Alnakaweh, and one written by Rav Yitzchak Abuhav I have heard that the latter was originally thought to be based on the previous work. Later I heard that many have disagreed and claimed the opposite to be true, and the Sefer of R' Abuhav came was the original Menoras Hamaor which the Menoras Hamaor of R' Al-Nakaweh was based on. I heard a 3rd opinion that they were written indepententally of each other without either affecting the other.

Can someone supply some more insight, sources, detail on this matter?

PS I would prefer, if available, a little more than just citings of sources stating one way or another.

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Between the two sefarim called ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor - One written by Rav Yisrael Al-Nakaweh, and one written by Rav Yitzchak Abuhav I have heard that the latter was originally thought to be based on the previous work. Later I heard that many have disagreed and claimed the opposite to be true, and the Sefer of R' Abuhav came was the original Menoras Hamaor which the Menoras Hamaor of R' Al-Nakaweh was based on. I heard a 3rd opinion that they were written indepententally of each other without either affecting the other.

Can someone supply some more insight, sources, detail on this matter?

PS I would prefer, if available, a little more than just citings of sources stating one way or another.

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Between the two sefarim called ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor - One written by Rav Yisrael ben Yoseph Alnakaweh, and one written by Rav Yitzchak Abuhav I have heard that the latter was originally thought to be based on the previous work. Later I heard that many have disagreed and claimed the opposite to be true, and the Sefer of R' Abuhav came was the original Menoras Hamaor which the Menoras Hamaor of R' Al-Nakaweh was based on. I heard a 3rd opinion that they were written indepententally of each other without either affecting the other.

Can someone supply some more insight, sources, detail on this matter?

PS I would prefer, if available, a little more than just citings of sources stating one way or another.

2 added 1 character in body
source | link

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Between the two sefarim called ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor - One written by Rav Yisrael Al-Nakaweh, and one written by Rav Yitzchak abuhavAbuhav I have heard that the latter was originally thought to be based on the previous work. Later I heard that many have disagreed and claimed the opposite to be true, and the Sefer of R' Abuhav came was the original Menoras Hamaor which the Menoras Hamaor of R' Al-Nakaweh was based on. I heard a 3rd opinion that they were written indepententally of each other without either affecting the other.

Can someone supply some more insight, sources, detail on this matter?

PS I woldwould prefer, if available, a little more than just citings of sources stating one way or another.

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Between the two sefarim called ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor - One written by Rav Yisrael Al-Nakaweh, and one written by Rav Yitzchak abuhav I have heard that the latter was originally thought to be based on the previous work. Later I heard that many have disagreed and claimed the opposite to be true, and the Sefer of R' Abuhav came was the original Menoras Hamaor which the Menoras Hamaor of R' Al-Nakaweh was based on. I heard a 3rd opinion that they were written indepententally of each other without either affecting the other.

Can someone supply some more insight, sources, detail on this matter?

PS I wold prefer, if available, a little more than just citings of sources stating one way or another.

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Between the two sefarim called ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor - One written by Rav Yisrael Al-Nakaweh, and one written by Rav Yitzchak Abuhav I have heard that the latter was originally thought to be based on the previous work. Later I heard that many have disagreed and claimed the opposite to be true, and the Sefer of R' Abuhav came was the original Menoras Hamaor which the Menoras Hamaor of R' Al-Nakaweh was based on. I heard a 3rd opinion that they were written indepententally of each other without either affecting the other.

Can someone supply some more insight, sources, detail on this matter?

PS I would prefer, if available, a little more than just citings of sources stating one way or another.

1
source | link

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Which ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor came first?

Between the two sefarim called ספר מנורת המאור Sefer Menoras Hamaor - One written by Rav Yisrael Al-Nakaweh, and one written by Rav Yitzchak abuhav I have heard that the latter was originally thought to be based on the previous work. Later I heard that many have disagreed and claimed the opposite to be true, and the Sefer of R' Abuhav came was the original Menoras Hamaor which the Menoras Hamaor of R' Al-Nakaweh was based on. I heard a 3rd opinion that they were written indepententally of each other without either affecting the other.

Can someone supply some more insight, sources, detail on this matter?

PS I wold prefer, if available, a little more than just citings of sources stating one way or another.