2 deleted 370 characters in body
source | link

The Shulchan Aruch says a Shochet must be “yodea Sefer”, meaning he needs to be able to learn inside, Gemara, Shulchan Aruch, etc. Yet it does not specify that he learn the Halachos from any particular source. So in theory, as long as he knows how to learn in Hebrew, he could learn the halachos of shechita from a translated text, just as he could learn them Baal peh from his rebbe without a text. That said, thereThere are many rabbeimrabbonim who won’t give kabbala to a Shochet that doesn’t show a strong grasp of the Hebrew terms and precise language of the text in Hebrew. Potential Shochetim have failed tests because they answered all the questions in English, even though the answers were correct. I’ve been teaching shechita for years and this is my experience with the students I’ve sent to be tested. (There was even one Rav who only wanted to see the student read and explain a random Halacha in the Shulchan Aruch as his test.)

The Shulchan Aruch says a Shochet must be “yodea Sefer”, meaning he needs to be able to learn inside, Gemara, Shulchan Aruch, etc. Yet it does not specify that he learn the Halachos from any particular source. So in theory, as long as he knows how to learn in Hebrew, he could learn the halachos of shechita from a translated text, just as he could learn them Baal peh from his rebbe without a text. That said, there are many rabbeim who won’t give kabbala to a Shochet that doesn’t show a strong grasp of the Hebrew terms and precise language of the text in Hebrew. Potential Shochetim have failed tests because they answered all the questions in English, even though the answers were correct. I’ve been teaching shechita for years and this is my experience. (There was even one Rav who only wanted to see the student read and explain a random Halacha in the Shulchan Aruch as his test.)

There are many rabbonim who won’t give kabbala to a Shochet that doesn’t show a strong grasp of the Hebrew terms and precise language of the text in Hebrew. Potential Shochetim have failed tests because they answered all the questions in English, even though the answers were correct. I’ve been teaching shechita for years and this is my experience with the students I’ve sent to be tested. (There was even one Rav who only wanted to see the student read and explain a random Halacha in the Shulchan Aruch as his test.)

1
source | link

The Shulchan Aruch says a Shochet must be “yodea Sefer”, meaning he needs to be able to learn inside, Gemara, Shulchan Aruch, etc. Yet it does not specify that he learn the Halachos from any particular source. So in theory, as long as he knows how to learn in Hebrew, he could learn the halachos of shechita from a translated text, just as he could learn them Baal peh from his rebbe without a text. That said, there are many rabbeim who won’t give kabbala to a Shochet that doesn’t show a strong grasp of the Hebrew terms and precise language of the text in Hebrew. Potential Shochetim have failed tests because they answered all the questions in English, even though the answers were correct. I’ve been teaching shechita for years and this is my experience. (There was even one Rav who only wanted to see the student read and explain a random Halacha in the Shulchan Aruch as his test.)