Skip to main content
Mi Yodeya

Return to Answer

made the link into a link
Source Link
MTL
MTL
  • 19.3k
  • 4
  • 53
  • 172

I've seen a bunch of people bring umbrellas to shul on Shabbat and leave them open during in the coat room during service. I know you're not supposed to open an umbrella on shabbat but there's a different rule for carrying an already open umbrella. If you open the umbrella before shabbat it's permissible in an erev. The torahmusings link ( torahmusings.com/2010/11/umbrellas-on-shabbat)torahmusings link suggests that you may give the appearance of breaking shabbat rules. That varies from shul to shul. In areas where it rains a lot, more observant people know the umbrella nuances.

I've seen a bunch of people bring umbrellas to shul on Shabbat and leave them open during in the coat room during service. I know you're not supposed to open an umbrella on shabbat but there's a different rule for carrying an already open umbrella. If you open the umbrella before shabbat it's permissible in an erev. The torahmusings link ( torahmusings.com/2010/11/umbrellas-on-shabbat) suggests that you may give the appearance of breaking shabbat rules. That varies from shul to shul. In areas where it rains a lot, more observant people know the umbrella nuances.

I've seen a bunch of people bring umbrellas to shul on Shabbat and leave them open during in the coat room during service. I know you're not supposed to open an umbrella on shabbat but there's a different rule for carrying an already open umbrella. If you open the umbrella before shabbat it's permissible in an erev. The torahmusings link suggests that you may give the appearance of breaking shabbat rules. That varies from shul to shul. In areas where it rains a lot, more observant people know the umbrella nuances.

added 49 characters in body
Source Link
sharkydora
sharkydora
  • 155
  • 6

I've seen a bunch of people bring umbrellas to shul on Shabbat and leave them open during in the coat room during service. I know you're not supposed to open an umbrella on shabbat but there's a different rule for carrying an already open umbrella. If you open the umbrella before shabbat it's permissible in an erev. The torahmusings link ( torahmusings.com/2010/11/umbrellas-on-shabbat) suggests that you may give the appearance of breaking shabbat rules. That varies from shul to shul. In areas where it rains a lot, more observant people know the umbrella nuances.

I've seen a bunch of people bring umbrellas to shul on Shabbat and leave them open during in the coat room during service. I know you're not supposed to open an umbrella on shabbat but there's a different rule for carrying an already open umbrella. If you open the umbrella before shabbat it's permissible in an erev. The torahmusings link suggests that you may give the appearance of breaking shabbat rules. That varies from shul to shul. In areas where it rains a lot, more observant people know the umbrella nuances.

I've seen a bunch of people bring umbrellas to shul on Shabbat and leave them open during in the coat room during service. I know you're not supposed to open an umbrella on shabbat but there's a different rule for carrying an already open umbrella. If you open the umbrella before shabbat it's permissible in an erev. The torahmusings link ( torahmusings.com/2010/11/umbrellas-on-shabbat) suggests that you may give the appearance of breaking shabbat rules. That varies from shul to shul. In areas where it rains a lot, more observant people know the umbrella nuances.

Source Link
sharkydora
sharkydora
  • 155
  • 6

I've seen a bunch of people bring umbrellas to shul on Shabbat and leave them open during in the coat room during service. I know you're not supposed to open an umbrella on shabbat but there's a different rule for carrying an already open umbrella. If you open the umbrella before shabbat it's permissible in an erev. The torahmusings link suggests that you may give the appearance of breaking shabbat rules. That varies from shul to shul. In areas where it rains a lot, more observant people know the umbrella nuances.