Skip to main content
Mi Yodeya

Return to Answer

English
Source Link
msh210 ♦
msh210 ♦
  • 74.1k
  • 12
  • 122
  • 370

if iIf I remember correctly i, I once saw in Kriene d'isgresaD'igresa from the steiplerSteipler that we can be machriadecide a machlokes rishonim based ofon archeological findings. theThe head of the living torah musuem r deutchLiving Torah Musuem, R. Deutch, once brought a coin that a diver had found on the bottom of the ocean off of france, itFrance and that was identified as a tyreTyre coin, r deutch. R. Deutch asked thatwhether, since there is a machlokes rashibetween Rashi and rambamRambam in regards to the wieghtweight, can we be machriacan decide the machlokes based off theon weighing off this coin, it. It turned out to be like the shitaview of the rambamRambam and iI think r elyashivR. Elyashiv exclaimed "well iI guess we see the rambamRambam was right!"

if i remember correctly i once saw in Kriene d'isgresa from the steipler that we can be machria machlokes rishonim based of archeological findings. the head of the living torah musuem r deutch once brought a coin diver found on the bottom of the ocean off of france, it was identified as a tyre coin, r deutch asked that since there is a machlokes rashi and rambam in regards to the wieght, can we be machria the machlokes based off the weighing off this coin, it turned out to be like the shita of the rambam and i think r elyashiv exclaimed "well i guess we see the rambam was right!"

If I remember correctly, I once saw in Kriene D'igresa from the Steipler that we can decide a machlokes rishonim based on archeological findings. The head of the Living Torah Musuem, R. Deutch, once brought a coin that a diver had found on the bottom of the ocean off of France and that was identified as a Tyre coin. R. Deutch asked whether, since there is a machlokes between Rashi and Rambam in regards to the weight, we can decide the machlokes based on weighing this coin. It turned out to be like the view of the Rambam and I think R. Elyashiv exclaimed "well I guess we see the Rambam was right!"

Source Link
user5519
user5519

if i remember correctly i once saw in Kriene d'isgresa from the steipler that we can be machria machlokes rishonim based of archeological findings. the head of the living torah musuem r deutch once brought a coin diver found on the bottom of the ocean off of france, it was identified as a tyre coin, r deutch asked that since there is a machlokes rashi and rambam in regards to the wieght, can we be machria the machlokes based off the weighing off this coin, it turned out to be like the shita of the rambam and i think r elyashiv exclaimed "well i guess we see the rambam was right!"