Timeline for Where do the te'amim variants in Bereishit 48:20-22 in Simanim come from?
Current License: CC BY-SA 4.0
9 events
| when toggle format | what | by | license | comment | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9 hours ago | comment | added | Colin Watson | It's true that this answer doesn't precisely identify the origin of these two variants. I suppose I wasn't exactly expecting that, but the pointer to MAM's detailed tables is still very useful to me. The last parashah I prepared included a vocalization difference between Leningrad and most Tiberian manuscripts, which also puzzled me for a while until I was able to track it down. Admittedly the practical answer is probably going to be "find out what the gabbai is likely to have in front of them", but that's less good for my curiosity! | |
| 19 hours ago | comment | added | EraserX | ok, got it, thx. | |
| 19 hours ago | comment | added | Double AA♦ | No, that's not my point. A long list of later printed editions is not all that valuable, all copying from each other. Trying to trace where the variant started would be. The question sought "the source of these particular variations" and you are just showing some random later printing which is almost surely not THE source of this variant. | |
| 19 hours ago | comment | added | EraserX | True, a nice improvement would be to list which particular דפוסים. You might want to suggest that to them as they are very open to input (though typically a small number of people in their edit history so any sweeping changes might not occur so soon). For what it's worth, I just edited info re: which דפוס the image above is from. | |
| 19 hours ago | history | edited | EraserX | CC BY-SA 4.0 |
added reference to מקראות גדולות דפוס נעטטער
|
| 21 hours ago | comment | added | Double AA♦ | The catchall דפוסים is hardly specific and doesn't really help us understand where the variant came from. This is just the project's way of saying "something later" | |
| 23 hours ago | vote | accept | Colin Watson | ||
| 23 hours ago | comment | added | Colin Watson | Amazing, thank you so much! | |
| yesterday | history | answered | EraserX | CC BY-SA 4.0 |