Skip to main content
added 52 characters in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38

NO.

First of all, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Now, you are also ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardi one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered speaking nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazimeveryone should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible (although that ruling is obviously not widely accepted).
  There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, writing about “our shame” and even “constant transgression” that he and his community couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know good pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having an old Mesorah is valuable.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction"Introduction to Tephillath Kol Peh", Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s Yaskil Avdi volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s Sidrei Esh volumevol. II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s Rav Pealim volumevol. II answerresponse 25.

NO.

First of all, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Now, you are also ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardi one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered speaking nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazim should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible.
  There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, writing about “our shame” and even “constant transgression” that he and his community couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know good pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having an old Mesorah is valuable.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction to Tephillath Kol Peh, Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s Yaskil Avdi volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s Sidrei Esh volume II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s Rav Pealim volume II answer 25.

NO.

First of all, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Now, you are also ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardi one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered speaking nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that everyone should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible (although that ruling is obviously not widely accepted). There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, writing about “our shame” and even “constant transgression” that he and his community couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know good pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having an old Mesorah is valuable.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s "Introduction to Tephillath Kol Peh", Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s Yaskil Avdi volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s Sidrei Esh vol. II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s Rav Pealim vol. II response 25.

added 2 characters in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38

NO.

First of all, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Now, you are also ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a SephardicSephardi one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered absolutespeaking nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazim should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible.

There
There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, and wrote onwriting about “our shame” and even “regular“constant transgression” that he and his community had because they couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know the correctgood pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having such an old Mesorah is valuable.

Now, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim in other areas, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction to “Tephillath Kol Peh”Tephillath Kol Peh, Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s “Yaskil Avdi”Yaskil Avdi volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s “Sidrei Esh”Sidrei Esh volume II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s “Rav Pealim”Rav Pealim volume II answer 25.

NO.

First of all, you are ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardic one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered absolute nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazim should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible.

There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, and wrote on “our shame” and even “regular transgression” that he and his community had because they couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know the correct pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having such an old Mesorah is valuable.

Now, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim in other areas, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction to “Tephillath Kol Peh”, Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s “Yaskil Avdi” volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s “Sidrei Esh” volume II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s “Rav Pealim” volume II answer 25.

NO.

First of all, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Now, you are also ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardi one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered speaking nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazim should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible.
There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, writing about “our shame” and even “constant transgression” that he and his community couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know good pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having an old Mesorah is valuable.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction to Tephillath Kol Peh, Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s Yaskil Avdi volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s Sidrei Esh volume II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s Rav Pealim volume II answer 25.

added 2 characters in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38

NO.

First of all, you are ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardic one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered absolute nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazim should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible.

There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, and wrote on “our shame” and even “regular transgression” that he and his community had because they couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know the correct pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having such an old Mesorah is valuable.

Now, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim in other areas, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardiyou're stuck a Sephardi.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction to “Tephillath Kol Peh”, Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s “Yaskil Avdi” volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s “Sidrei Esh” volume II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s “Rav Pealim” volume II answer 25.

NO.

First of all, you are ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardic one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered absolute nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazim should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible.

There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, and wrote on “our shame” and even “regular transgression” that he and his community had because they couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know the correct pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having such an old Mesorah is valuable.

Now, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim in other areas, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction to “Tephillath Kol Peh”, Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s “Yaskil Avdi” volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s “Sidrei Esh” volume II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s “Rav Pealim” volume II answer 25.

NO.

First of all, you are ENTIRELY forbidden from adopting an Ashkenazi pronunciation over a Sephardic one. Because you are capable of pronouncing the Hebrew letters distinctly, pronouncing them differently would be considered absolute nonsense. In fact, many Rabbis, both Ashkenazi and Sephardi, have ruled that Ashkenazim should adopt distinct pronunciations of letters wherever possible.

There are tens of Rabbinical sources, many of them famous, one of the most persuading being the Yavetz. He was always extremely critical of his own congregation’s Hebrew pronunciation, and wrote on “our shame” and even “regular transgression” that he and his community had because they couldn’t pronounce Hebrew correctly. If he knew the correct pronunciations, he obviously would have tried adopting them.

You already know the correct pronunciation. Your tradition from your parents is a privilege. Don’t allow yourself to forget it. Having such an old Mesorah is valuable.

Now, regarding switching to Ashkenazi minhagim in other areas, Rav Ovadia forbids it. Ashkenazim are allowed to replace their Minhagim with the Sephardic Minhag, not the other way around. Sorry, but that’s how it is; you're stuck a Sephardi.

Other sources include: Rav Yihya Yishai Hallewi’s introduction to “Tephillath Kol Peh”, Rav Ovadia Hadaya’s “Yaskil Avdi” volume II chapter 13, Rav Yehiel Weinberg’s “Sidrei Esh” volume II chapter 5, and Ben Ish Hai’s “Rav Pealim” volume II answer 25.

deleted 109 characters in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38
Loading
deleted 1 character in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38
Loading
added sources the OP provided in comments
Source Link
mbloch
  • 54k
  • 10
  • 98
  • 257
Loading
added 188 characters in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38
Loading
added 91 characters in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38
Loading
added 38 characters in body
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38
Loading
Source Link
Qwertrl
  • 1.9k
  • 1
  • 7
  • 38
Loading