Skip to main content
added 621 characters in body
Source Link
Lo ani
  • 5k
  • 2
  • 9
  • 51

The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 334:12) says:

כל כתבי הקודש מצילין האידנא מפני הדליקה קורין בהם אפי' כתובים בכל לשון אפי' כתובים בסם ובסיקרא (פירוש מיני צבעים) ובכל דבר וכן מטבע ברכות שטבעו חכמים מצילים אותם מן הדליקה...

In these days, all holy scriptures are saved from a fire and read from [publicly], even if they are written in any language and even if they are written with dye or red paint (meaning types of paint) or anything else. Similarly, a set of blessings that the Sages established [i.e., a siddur] should be saved from a fire...

(Sefaria's translation, my emphasis)

The Mishna Berura explains (seif katan 33)

וכן מטבע ברכות: שכל זה הותר לכתוב בזמנינו ולברך ולהתפלל בם משום עת לעשות לה' וע"כ ממילא צריך להצילם מן הדליקה וגם טעונים גניזה בחול שלא יהיו מונחים במקום הפקר

Similarly a set of blessings: For all of this was allowed to be written in our times and to bless and pray from them because of 'a time to do for HaShem and therefore one must save them from a fire, and they need burial on weekdays so that they will not be left in an abandoned place

Meaning, because siddurs were allowed to be written, they now need to be saved from a fire. Since the reason to not write siddurim no longer applies, and they'll be saved anyway, having HaShems name written out is no longer considered "as if he is a burner of the Torah", and it would be allowed.


In regards to Lifnei Iver, it's possible that the first printers who printed in such a way we're Over the Aveira. However, subsequent printers wouldn't be, because Lifnei Iver is only if the one doing the sin wouldn't have been able to do it without the 'help' of the other, IIRC. However, it would still be מסייע לידי עובר עבירה.

Additionally, presumably almost anyone who we might worry won't know how to pronounce HaShems name (i.e. YKVK) are k'tanim, and probably even below / just barely chinuch age, in which case there might not be a worry of Lifnei Iver or מסייע לידי עובר עבירה to begin with.

The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 334:12) says:

כל כתבי הקודש מצילין האידנא מפני הדליקה קורין בהם אפי' כתובים בכל לשון אפי' כתובים בסם ובסיקרא (פירוש מיני צבעים) ובכל דבר וכן מטבע ברכות שטבעו חכמים מצילים אותם מן הדליקה...

In these days, all holy scriptures are saved from a fire and read from [publicly], even if they are written in any language and even if they are written with dye or red paint (meaning types of paint) or anything else. Similarly, a set of blessings that the Sages established [i.e., a siddur] should be saved from a fire...

(Sefaria's translation, my emphasis)

The Mishna Berura explains (seif katan 33)

וכן מטבע ברכות: שכל זה הותר לכתוב בזמנינו ולברך ולהתפלל בם משום עת לעשות לה' וע"כ ממילא צריך להצילם מן הדליקה וגם טעונים גניזה בחול שלא יהיו מונחים במקום הפקר

Similarly a set of blessings: For all of this was allowed to be written in our times and to bless and pray from them because of 'a time to do for HaShem and therefore one must save them from a fire, and they need burial on weekdays so that they will not be left in an abandoned place

Meaning, because siddurs were allowed to be written, they now need to be saved from a fire. Since the reason to not write siddurim no longer applies, and they'll be saved anyway, having HaShems name written out is no longer considered "as if he is a burner of the Torah", and it would be allowed.

The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 334:12) says:

כל כתבי הקודש מצילין האידנא מפני הדליקה קורין בהם אפי' כתובים בכל לשון אפי' כתובים בסם ובסיקרא (פירוש מיני צבעים) ובכל דבר וכן מטבע ברכות שטבעו חכמים מצילים אותם מן הדליקה...

In these days, all holy scriptures are saved from a fire and read from [publicly], even if they are written in any language and even if they are written with dye or red paint (meaning types of paint) or anything else. Similarly, a set of blessings that the Sages established [i.e., a siddur] should be saved from a fire...

(Sefaria's translation, my emphasis)

The Mishna Berura explains (seif katan 33)

וכן מטבע ברכות: שכל זה הותר לכתוב בזמנינו ולברך ולהתפלל בם משום עת לעשות לה' וע"כ ממילא צריך להצילם מן הדליקה וגם טעונים גניזה בחול שלא יהיו מונחים במקום הפקר

Similarly a set of blessings: For all of this was allowed to be written in our times and to bless and pray from them because of 'a time to do for HaShem and therefore one must save them from a fire, and they need burial on weekdays so that they will not be left in an abandoned place

Meaning, because siddurs were allowed to be written, they now need to be saved from a fire. Since the reason to not write siddurim no longer applies, and they'll be saved anyway, having HaShems name written out is no longer considered "as if he is a burner of the Torah", and it would be allowed.


In regards to Lifnei Iver, it's possible that the first printers who printed in such a way we're Over the Aveira. However, subsequent printers wouldn't be, because Lifnei Iver is only if the one doing the sin wouldn't have been able to do it without the 'help' of the other, IIRC. However, it would still be מסייע לידי עובר עבירה.

Additionally, presumably almost anyone who we might worry won't know how to pronounce HaShems name (i.e. YKVK) are k'tanim, and probably even below / just barely chinuch age, in which case there might not be a worry of Lifnei Iver or מסייע לידי עובר עבירה to begin with.

Source Link
Lo ani
  • 5k
  • 2
  • 9
  • 51

The Shulchan Aruch (Orach Chayim 334:12) says:

כל כתבי הקודש מצילין האידנא מפני הדליקה קורין בהם אפי' כתובים בכל לשון אפי' כתובים בסם ובסיקרא (פירוש מיני צבעים) ובכל דבר וכן מטבע ברכות שטבעו חכמים מצילים אותם מן הדליקה...

In these days, all holy scriptures are saved from a fire and read from [publicly], even if they are written in any language and even if they are written with dye or red paint (meaning types of paint) or anything else. Similarly, a set of blessings that the Sages established [i.e., a siddur] should be saved from a fire...

(Sefaria's translation, my emphasis)

The Mishna Berura explains (seif katan 33)

וכן מטבע ברכות: שכל זה הותר לכתוב בזמנינו ולברך ולהתפלל בם משום עת לעשות לה' וע"כ ממילא צריך להצילם מן הדליקה וגם טעונים גניזה בחול שלא יהיו מונחים במקום הפקר

Similarly a set of blessings: For all of this was allowed to be written in our times and to bless and pray from them because of 'a time to do for HaShem and therefore one must save them from a fire, and they need burial on weekdays so that they will not be left in an abandoned place

Meaning, because siddurs were allowed to be written, they now need to be saved from a fire. Since the reason to not write siddurim no longer applies, and they'll be saved anyway, having HaShems name written out is no longer considered "as if he is a burner of the Torah", and it would be allowed.