1,942 reputation
322
bio website
location New York, NY
age
visits member for 2 years, 6 months
seen Mar 26 at 14:59

Dec
13
comment What are the sources for women to wear/ not wear pants?
@SethJ He writes "there is no issur; on the contrary, yesh bo mishum tzenius" - I understood this as a polar contrast: not only is there no issur, but it's actually an example of good tzenius.
Dec
13
comment Tznius of the times
Pants depends on whom you ask; see my answer to this related question
Dec
7
comment Does amirah L'akum apply to robots?
what @DoubleAA said. If we really want to go sci-fi, the question could spill out into "is a sentient android considered human for the purposes of agency in the Torah". It must be Friday.
Nov
26
comment Inhaling prayers?
I was trying to get around to asking this; thank you for posting!
Nov
20
comment Cold-brew coffee on Shabbos
@sam well, that's the question: is there any melachah here. Apparently there's no problem brewing tea, but that is only steeped for a short time. Could it be dash?
Nov
20
comment Cold-brew coffee on Shabbos
I explicitly excluded straining from the question. Based on your feedback, I removed reference to the press.
Nov
12
comment Why should one have marital relations as if forced by a demon?
It was clear to me in my own chasan class, as well as a reinforcement session I had with another rav later, who was a talmid of R' Henkin, that I was not encouraged to follow this halachah. I still don't understand what the fact of it being in SA is actually supposed to mean.
Nov
11
comment Circumcision when danger to life, born Jews and potential gerim
Ask Skylar at the blog...
Nov
5
comment Do those who practice family purity get cervical cancer less?
Try this search on PubMed ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/…
Aug
22
comment Learning secular topics for parnassah
The question works in theory, but in practice (at least in the professions), I don't think curtailing continuing education is a good idea. One wouldn't remain competitive that way. Additionally, there are precious few professions where one can coast and still meet his financial obligations in today's Orthodox world.
Aug
8
comment What does “twice in seven years” mean regarding checking mezuzos?
@ba if it's viewed as a cycle, I can check in years 2, 4, 9, 13, and 5-11 have passed with only one check.
Aug
7
comment What does “twice in seven years” mean regarding checking mezuzos?
@ba does it mean, then, that there should be no seven-year period without two checkings? Or is it a repeating seven-year cycle, where you might have seven years pass without a check?
Jul
27
comment Paying bill for aveirah already done
@msh210 yes, but it's the act that's impermissible, not the payment - no? I would think even more so with the animal, since the payment does not degrade the act any more, as opposed to the zenus.
Jul
23
comment Invitation to nonkosher restaurant
This is a valuable question, but you should modify it to be more general rather than personal advice - see meta.judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/312/… -- and ask your rav!
Jul
5
comment Biography on Rav Hirsch
@MatthewMiller The Klugmann is a pretty well-researched and balanced work.
Jul
2
comment Source for the practice of not blowing out candles/flames?
@sam me neither, at least in Hebrewbooks, assuming the sefer I found there is the one they're talking about.
Jun
26
comment Bracha on Smoking
@msh210 conceptually I would think of that as "mis'asek," or whatever the equivalent is in this context. I don't have the background in actual talmudic concepts to confirm that "authoritatively," but it's hard for me to conceive of that being significant enough for a berachah.
Jun
25
comment Bracha on Smoking
@msh210 I simply don't understand how random particles of tobacco that mistakenly end up getting routed to the stomach instead of the lungs, can be called eating. It's totally unintentional; if I walk through a smoky room, presumably the same thing happens, yet it would be absurd to say a berachah there.
Jun
25
comment Is one allowed to drink alcohol on regular weekdays?
Why would one think otherwise?
Jun
25
comment Bracha on Smoking
@DoubleAA true enough, but the implication in the question was an eating berachah due to the ingestion of tobacco. But to address your point, I find it unlikely that cigarette smokers savor the fragrance, though I could be wrong. For cigars and pipes, on the other hand, I could hear that much better.