8,862 reputation
1940
bio website
location Manchester, United Kingdom
age 70
visits member for 1 year, 10 months
seen 22 hours ago
stats profile views 144

May
10
comment What if someone is unable to believe in God?
Try amazon.com/Permission-To-Believe-Approaches-Existence/dp/… "Permission To Believe: Four Rational Approaches to God's Existence" by Rabbi L Kelemen.
May
9
comment When the first of the 3 days of hagbalah is Sunday, are haircuts permitted the Friday before?
@SethJ Indeed. Yes.
May
9
comment HaKohen, HaLevi - source and reason
Kohanim do not go up to duchan with laced shoes. According to Rav Ashi the reason is that Kohanim have to be careful not be thought of as a chalal (invalid Kohen). I suggest that the reason for writing after HaKohen their names is to show that they are genuine kohanim and not chalalim. I don’t have the same justification for the Leviyim.
May
8
comment Are homeopathic remedies kosher?
But if there is not a single molecule present - then there is nothing there of it. This is not a question of bittul - it's a question of existence (so to speak).
May
5
comment How to care about the molad
But do you remember the time of the molad till the last time for kiddush levonoh?
May
2
comment Is Chazaq Chazaq v'nitchazeq חזק חזק ונתחזק an interruption for the reader?
@DoubleAA Is it worth asking the question in the case where the Ba'al Keriyah is the Oleh as well?
Apr
30
comment Where does it say that one must wear two layers on their head(one of the reasons for the black hat)?
Please see my question judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/11004/… and some of the answers comments which relate to your comment.
Apr
22
comment May one say the letters of Hashem's name i.e. “Yud hei vov hei”?
@SethJ Yes - but the letters Yud Kei (and Vov Kei, my Rav tells me) create a name of Hashem on their own.
Apr
21
comment May one say the letters of Hashem's name i.e. “Yud hei vov hei”?
@SethJ Yes it is. But I don't see your point. BTW the Gr"a did not say any "leshem Yichud"s.
Apr
21
comment May one say the letters of Hashem's name i.e. “Yud hei vov hei”?
BTW, the marginal note in Sukkah refers to two other Tosafos. Shevuos 35a s.v. b'alef dales agrees with Tosafos in Sukkah that is that without intention for the name is not a problem. Avodo Zoro 18a s.v. hog'e says that one should not mention even the letters yud hei - and does not speak about intention.
Apr
21
comment May one say the letters of Hashem's name i.e. “Yud hei vov hei”?
@DoubleAA Thank you. Incorporated your comment into the question.
Apr
19
comment Can I prevent trespass through (for example) my garden?
@DannySchoemann Do you have a source for that please?
Apr
17
comment Am I allowed to wear my Pebble Watch on Shabbat?
The question seems to be a special case of this question judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/8725/… "What is a watch one can wear on shabbat?". See the discussion there.
Apr
17
comment Can I prevent trespass through (for example) my garden?
I would certainly like to know the law outside of Israel (as well as in Israel).
Apr
17
comment Singing Lecha Dodi before Shabbos
related judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/13713/…
Apr
17
comment Can I prevent trespass through (for example) my garden?
זה נהנה וזה לא חסר and/or הזק ראיה אין שמו היזק I don't know
Apr
12
comment Why do we not reply to “Mazel Tov” with “Tov Mazel”?
@SethJ Pischei Teshuvos quotes one source who does not like Kohanim responding Baruch Tihyeh to Y"K after blessing the people in case they are adding to the blessing. He recommends K"Y. No, I didn't change it.
Apr
9
comment How to handle cadavers
@DoubleAA But if you did know?
Apr
9
comment How to handle cadavers
What about a cadaver that is or is likely to be Jewish?
Apr
5
comment What are the reasons that chewing cud is a kosher sign?
Try Horeb, Rabbi S R Hirsch z”l and this book on the dietary laws by the Dayan I Grunfeld z”l.