21,175 reputation
33198
bio website
location
age
visits member for 4 years, 8 months
seen yesterday

Jul
28
comment Where to keep holy books
Where did you hear this, and was there some defining characteristic of the bedroom that was mentioned (a room with a bed, a room with a couch upon which someone sleeps occasionally, frequently, regularly, room in an abandoned warehouse in which someone retreats for some quiet rest but likes to learn on his way to/from and so carries said book...)?
Jul
28
comment Sitting at the same level as Holy Books
"What about the same level?" Well, what about it?
Jul
28
revised Eating food during the 9 days that's been cooked with meat
edited title
Jul
28
comment Is there an 'Inyan of Upsherin for girls?
@DannySchoemann and judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/8212/…
Jul
28
comment What is the source for the “Upsheirin”?
@joshwaxman, "an Old German superstition could work its way into Germanic Jewish custom," much as an old custom of ancient Jewish immigrants to Germanic lands could have worked its way into Germanic superstition.
Jul
28
comment Is there an 'Inyan of Upsherin for girls?
@DannySchoemann: judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/8212/…
Jul
28
comment Keeping up with “local” standards of modesty and dress - of religious Jews, or of society at large
@JJLL, but shouldn't we strive to dress distinctively? My point above was just that, although we would not dress like we do today, that does not mean that we did not have a distinct form of dress way back when. In other words, just because we may have been living in the Middle East, that doesn't mean we dressed like Arabs.
Jul
25
revised Keeping up with “local” standards of modesty and dress - of religious Jews, or of society at large
added 33 characters in body; edited title
Jul
25
comment Keeping up with “local” standards of modesty and dress - of religious Jews, or of society at large
@JJLL, I don't know why you assume we'd look Muslim. I agree, however, that we would not dress as we do today.
Jul
24
comment Keeping up with “local” standards of modesty and dress - of religious Jews, or of society at large
@double I don't. But I am basically asking, just because they don't, does that mean the Halachic norm changes to match society? Wouldn't there at least be an argument that whatever outside influences may exist, they shouldn't "count" in determining the "local" standard?
Jul
24
comment Does breast milk make vessels non-kosher or milchig?
@DanF, so, one of the restrictions in the ruling above (which is really straight out of the Shulhan 'Aruch) is that it is Kosher if it is in a vessel. Basically, an adult is not permitted to nurse; I cannot recall offhand, and am unable to look up right now, if it's considered disgusting, and the prohibition of Bal TiShaketzu applies, or if it's something else.
Jul
24
comment Does breast milk make vessels non-kosher or milchig?
@DanF, the link is a Teshuvah that says mother's milk is Mutar for adults to drink (with two circumstantial exceptions, but the basic law is Heter).
Jul
22
comment Reason for various positioning of “An'im Zemirot”
@NoachmiFrankfurt, I know several Minyanim that don't recite it at all because it is Shir HaKavod, and we generally (and a child especially) are not on the level where that is appropriate. Certainly one should at least understand what he is saying, no?
Jul
22
revised Can someone who is not wearing tefillin on a weekday receive an aliyah?
deleted 1 character in body
Jul
22
comment Call for Halachic Dateline Source(s)
@DoubleAA, before Magellan (and before commercial flight), wouldn't a traveler to a remote region continue his counting/dating from where he was yesterday? He would not be traveling vast distances in a matter of a few hours. Granted, he may lose track of his days if he's not paying attention or keeping a journal, but this is a question about the black letter of what is considered a Saturday, not what a loner in the wild should do if he loses track of his days.
Jul
21
revised Opening bottles and creating a Keli on Shabbath
added 41 characters in body
Jul
18
awarded  Nice Answer
Jul
17
revised Is one allowed to smoke?
added 34 characters in body
Jul
16
revised Is one allowed to smoke?
Adding that my point is first-hand testimony, both for the sake of the answer and for the sake of my memory in 10, 20 years when I stumble across this question on whatever future system takes the place of the internet.
Jul
16
revised Is one allowed to smoke?
Adding that my point is first-hand testimony, both for the sake of the answer and for the sake of my memory in 10, 20 years when I stumble across this question on whatever future system takes the place of the internet.