5,725 reputation
935
bio website schnittblox.com
location United States
age 37
visits member for 5 years, 7 months
seen Jun 30 at 20:03

who knows?


Mar
24
asked What makes something “chukat goyim?”
Mar
24
comment Should one drink from the leader's cup after kiddush?
I don't think I have ever seen the wine given to the lady of the house. I still don't see why this is "the best way to perform the mitzvah", and it seems to smack of somehow blessing the wine itself, something done in other religions that we generally try to distance ourselves from. which reminds me of another question re: chukat goyim.
Mar
24
comment Shisha - mi yodeya?
8 vertices, 12 edges, then how many "sides"? does each face have two, making 12 total?
Mar
23
asked Should one drink from the leader's cup after kiddush?
Mar
23
answered Shiv'a - mi yodeya?
Mar
23
answered Shisha - mi yodeya?
Mar
23
answered Shelosha - mi yodeya?
Mar
23
comment Shisha - mi yodeya?
similar: six are the tribes on the left shoulder, six are the tribes on the right shoulder (of the Cohen Gadol of course)
Mar
19
answered Arba'a - mi yodeya?
Mar
18
answered Is Christianity Avodah Zara?
Mar
18
comment Why do Jews physically resemble members of their “host” nationalities?
I would tend towards a 99-100% genetic explanation, with almost no contribution from cultural/diet/environment. Those may indirectly explain the differences between races evolving over thousands of years, but the fact that Syrian Jews all born and bred in Brooklyn are still easily distinguishable from their Ashkenazi neighbors is due to genetics. And within the genetic answer, my hunch is that conversion historically played a very small role, while intermarriage and other, more violent variants were the dominant factor in genetic mixing.
Mar
18
answered Shnayim - mi yodeya?
Mar
17
comment Do bananas make the best karpas?
why aren't parsley, onion, and potatoes ha'adama? what are some guaranteed haadamas? tomato? those would taste good with a little salt water. and cherry toms are almost certainly less than a k'zait
Mar
17
comment Kosher accommodations in out-of-the-way US places
that thread reminded me of the kosher B&B in Newport, RI. I've never been, but have heard great things about the town wrt vacation, and also of course there is the famous Touro Synagogue, which has davening on shabbos. AND there are direct flights from BWI-PVD via Southwest
Mar
16
comment Best practices for praying in public with talit and tefilin
After hearing about the NY flight, I did exactly this on a recent trip overseas. I davened shacharit w/o tallis/tefillin on the plane, then mincha with both at the hotel. My kavana was vastly improved, without worring about disturbing neighbors or scaring flight attendants. In fact, I find I can do some of my best davening on a plane, since I typically have tons of time, nobody is bothering me, and there is a very real (even if remote) possibility of imminent death.
Mar
16
comment Best practices for praying in public with talit and tefilin
Yes on (1), no on (2). I find that explanations almost always seem to cause more confusion than not.
Mar
16
comment Experience-based advice for focusing and slowing down prayers?
I was going to suggest Nusach Sefard also, but was wondering if there are any halakhic implications? I know that if you are in a shul davening Sefard, than you can also, even if you regularly daven Ashkenaz, but if you are Ashkenaz in an Ashkenaz shul, is there room to change minhag?
Mar
16
comment Kosher accommodations in out-of-the-way US places
There are also many kosher hotels in the Catskills, but if being surrounded by frum Jews doesn't feel like vacation, then you might have a problem.
Mar
16
comment What would you really, actually like to receive (give?) for Mishloach Manot on Purim?
I once got a bowl of soup handed to me for mishloach manot in yeshiva. talk about urgency!
Mar
16
comment Who hides the afikoman?
It definitely keeps them awake and interested in something, but it also distracts away from "the main point". Unless the main point really is just to keep them awake and entertained. As the father of young children, I know this really does have value, since the kids get excited and look forward to pesach, which literally gets stamped on their consciousness for years to come