Danield

1,755 reputation

214

bio	website	edenics.net
	location	Israel
	age	34
visits	member for	8 months
	seen	13 hours ago
stats	profile views	47

I'm a chossid of the Lubavitcher Rebbe

	1,755 reputation	bio	website	edenics.net	visits	member for	8 months
214 badges		location	Israel		seen	13 hours ago

summary answers questions tags badges favorites bounties reputation activity

264 Actions

suggestions reviews revisions comments badges posts accepts all

Nov 2	revised	Is there a way to tell if a Pitom of an Etrog has been broken, or was grown that way? added 1000 characters in body
Nov 2	awarded	Revival
Nov 2	revised	Is there a way to tell if a Pitom of an Etrog has been broken, or was grown that way? added 4 characters in body
Nov 1	answered	Is there a way to tell if a Pitom of an Etrog has been broken, or was grown that way?
Nov 1	accepted	“Avram” for when he was young?
Nov 1	accepted	Can Sforim be used as a shtender?
Oct 31	awarded	Nice Question
Oct 31	comment	Can Sforim be used as a shtender? @DoubleAA +1 thanks (but whose answer should i accept?...you answered first but Yehoshua's answer gives a broader picture )
Oct 30	revised	Can Sforim be used as a shtender? added 16 characters in body; edited tags
Oct 30	asked	Can Sforim be used as a shtender?
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? Furthermore , did you notice that the original question was only directed towards Chasidim - because - quite frankly - Jews from all other sectors of Judiasm wear ties. The only hava amina was with - pious - Chasidim
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? @DoubleAA in any case from the gist of my answer it is clear that your intentions will only help when we're talking about a 'neutral' object not a forbidden one. As I said above: in hachi nami: for those that say it's ossur- it's ossur! But if you insist, i'll edit out the bit about Chukas Akum
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? Are you saying that If you follow the Gra, then it's ossur to wear a tie? Something tells me this is wrong because i've seen religious Jews who follow the Gra and wear ties.
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? @DoubleAA: did you see Shalom's comment: "But R' Moshe Feinstein writes that American clothing styles are all about looking good (or trying?) and therefore not "senseless.
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? Excuse me? the whole basis of my answer was that ties are NOT formally forbidden but rather based on svoro/speculation. I tried reading the Gra but I don't think I fully understood it. In any case I didn't see any clear reference to ties. So no, I WAS NOT talking about a real issur deoraita. (Are you saying that it's mefurash in the Gra that wearing a tie is an issur deoraita??)
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? @DoubleAA There are Rabbis which say that internet is forbidden. If someone comes along and says: "wait a sec, but I only want to use it for a daily Torah shiur" - is this making a mockery of the halachik system?
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? You wouldn't pasken whether a tie is Chukos Hagoyim from a possuk, but rather from a Svoro like: 'it's a useless garment so which goyim wear, so therefore we shouldn't be wearing it' which is exactly what i'm been saying all along. In any case i'd like to see the tshuva you're referring to.
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? What i'm trying to say is that if there was a clear-cut halacha of Chukos HaGoyim - then there would be an outright issur and nobody would wear ties
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? So THOSE people shouldn't/don't wear ties (like I said in my answer)
Oct 29	comment	Do Chasidim avoid wearing ties? @Double AA :Which Tanna says that ties are Chukos Hagoyim?? The fact that many great Rabbis wear them is proof enough for me that it is not really 'Chukos Hagoyim' but only similar to it. For THIS I can say it depends on the wearer's intensions. If the tie had Shatnes in it however - then intensions wouldn't help ;)