6,025 reputation
821
bio website mekubal.wordpress.com
location Jerusalem
age 36
visits member for 3 years, 11 months
seen Jul 17 '13 at 22:25

Born in New Jersey, educated in Philadelphia, attained Semikha from Rabbinut in 2003, went on to become a Sofer, Mohel and Shochet. Currently studying Dayyanut and Kabbalah at Yeshivat HaMekubalim Nahar Shalom and Yeshivat HaMekubalim Beit El. Husband and father of four(for now).


Apr
16
comment Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
@MeirZirkind If you want to quote Aggadata, how about the famous one in Mnochot about the Tagin. Moshe Rabbeinu didn't understand them, but Rabbi Akiva would expound upon them. See also the Maharal of Prague on that piece. Most notably where he says the Moshe Rabbeinu was limited in the oral torah.
Apr
16
comment Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
@DoubleAA I've never heard that holding implies psak. I've always heard it as the English translation for סובר or סברא. That's how its used in the Yeshivish circles that I run in.
Apr
15
comment Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
@Michoel Why can't we hold like the Rambam, Ben Ish Hai, and other torah giants that said he only kept M'Doraitta and then only what made sense to him?
Apr
15
comment Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
@MeirZirkind Did Moshe Rabbeinu send Mishloach Manot on Purim? If not, assuming he received the entire Oral Torah including the Gemarras, why not? What about Tzom Gedeliah? Tisha B'Av, 17th of Tammuz?
Apr
15
comment Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
@IsaacMoses added some explanation.
Apr
15
comment Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
Does this statement include parts of the Talmud which seem to have been written in the time of the Geonim?
Apr
15
revised Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
added 82 characters in body
Apr
15
revised Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
added 315 characters in body
Apr
15
answered Talmud comes from Har Sinai?
Apr
15
awarded  Enthusiast
Apr
14
comment Kabala in Halacha
@Yehoshua That would depend on what you saw as the kula or chumra. I would say not wearing Tefllin on Chol HaMoed is L'Chumra, as in treating Chol HaMoed with a higher level of sanctity.
Apr
14
comment Is it forbidden to wear a snap-brim Borsolino fedora on Shabbos?
@ArielK A tefach is only 8cm(approx 3in) Many groups have hat brims that are 3-4in wide.
Apr
14
comment What do you have to check for Shatnez?
@HachamGabriel Halacha Berrura was page number. The problem is there is no sofek(or sfeik sfeika) when dealing with an Issur D'Oraitta as Rav Klein explains. The only time you can rely on a s'feik s'feika is in an issur d'rabbanan, which is a non-grament item(mattress, couch, rags, possibly gloves and socks). A suit is a garment according to Torah and thus it is an issur d'oraitta.
Apr
14
comment What do you have to check for Shatnez?
@HachamGabriel The Rav Ovadia Quote is from a written Teshuva republished in its entirety in Yeriat Shlomo 2 p. 330, and in Halakha Berrura 2:223(I believe). The Rav Hillel quote is from personal correspondence with him. Regarding the Mishne Halachot: ARE YOU KIDDING?!?! There he is only talking non-garments. He makes that abundantly clear throughout the Teshuva. Not a suit. A non-garment is a issur d'rabbanan(in which case a sofek goes l'kula), a garment is an issur d'orraitta(in which chase a sofek goes l'chumra).
Apr
13
comment What do you have to check for Shatnez?
@HachamGabriel Here is your avatar Rav Hillel, " Rav Abaddi is truly brilliant and widely despised. He has no concept of mesora or tradition or concern for any of the negative consequences of psak. When he was in Lakewood the first time - one of his sons was killed in a car crash - believed to be Divine punishment for his psakim. After that he move to Har Nof - where he had a Kollel and was driven out by the local Rabbinate. He moved back to Lakewood where he is widely scorned and Yirei Shamayim are careful not to quote him as their authority or call him rav.
Apr
13
comment What do you have to check for Shatnez?
@HachamGabriel I did read the article, and honestly it shows a horrible misunderstanding of the basic halakhot of Shatznaz. Important point, Rav Abadi himself has nothing to do with this website, it is run by his son, in the name of his father. I don't know Rabbi Maroof, but I do know Rav Ovadia Yosef, he writes regarding Rav Abadi, "אין לסמוך על רב עבאדי בכלל, הרי הוא חוטא ומחטיא את הרבים, והדבר מוכיח כי אין יראת ה' על פניו, ואוי לו מיום הדין."
Apr
12
comment What do you have to check for Shatnez?
@HachamGabriel First Rav Ovadia Yosef has long said that following Rav Abady will only bring one to sin. Second since when do we say Sofek D'oraitta L'Kulo? Third in general the tag of a garment only covers the broad clothe it is made from, not interlining, lining, and stiffeners. A 100% polyester suit is only a guarentee that the shell is 100%poly, not that suit is, nor that it doesn't have shatznaz. That is a simple fact known to anyone who has ever worked in the textile industry. But this is what I would expect from a Rav who says Hekhsherim are unnecessary.
Apr
12
comment What do you have to check for Shatnez?
Rav Abadi also says one may eat from non-kosher restaurants. He is not what I would consider the trustworthy source.
Apr
12
comment What about the Kohen?
@DoubleAA Which translated means, "I will bless them". So the Kohen does the blessing, which causes G-d to bless the people, but what about the Kohen?
Apr
12
asked What about the Kohen?