8,250 reputation
1740
bio website
location
age
visits member for 3 years, 1 month
seen 1 hour ago

Mar
16
revised Following both Rashi and Rabbeinu Tam (mezuzah, sefer torah and tefillin)
deleted 233 characters in body
Mar
16
comment Following both Rashi and Rabbeinu Tam (mezuzah, sefer torah and tefillin)
@DoubleAA - I see, but isn't the reason for the parchments being placed horizontal (acc. to RT) the same as his reason for placing the mezuzah horizontally - ie: that this is the way that the Torah was placed in the original aron? If so, my question still stands: why do we harmonise when it comes to the mezuzah (if the Maharil is correct, and that is truly the reason we do this) and not when it comes to other things? (I have deleted my final paragraph since it probably obscures my primary question; and you are right: it's not necessarily relevant).
Mar
16
asked Following both Rashi and Rabbeinu Tam (mezuzah, sefer torah and tefillin)
Mar
12
comment When was the Meiri discovered?
@Nafkamina - I think (but am not 100% sure) that the Meiri on Avodah Zarah was first published in the middle of the 20th century and that, prior to the 19th century, nobody even referred to his views on gentiles. I wonder if it is specifically this part of the Bet haBechirah that the Chazon Ish was referring to? Because the rest of his work is quoted hundreds of times by a range of different sources (most frequently by Shittah Mequbetzet, but also - as you point out - by the Biur Halakha).
Mar
11
comment When was the Meiri discovered?
@ShmuelBrin - I don't know where this idea came from, that nobody studied or quoted the Meiri before the 18th century, but I hear it again and again and it's completely untrue... For just one piece of evidence to the contrary, see the Shittah Mequbetzet on Bava Qama 113a, which was written in the 16th century: hebrewbooks.org/… (second paragraph of second column)
Mar
11
answered When was the Meiri discovered?
Mar
6
awarded  Nice Answer
Mar
6
asked Who should one credit? A question on the Bartenura
Mar
6
comment Resurrection of the dead - when did this concept started?
@DoubleAA - I misspoke, sorry.
Mar
5
comment Understanding Megillah 3a
Great question! Note, however, that the Targum actually provides two interpretations, not one: the mourning of Hadadrimon in Megiddo corresponds to the death of Ahab (killed by Hadadrimon) and also to the death of Josiah (killed in Megiddo). Note also that Rashi (Zech 12:11) says exactly the same thing.
Mar
4
comment Resurrection of the dead - when did this concept started?
Seeing as Hosea makes reference to the return of the prophet Elijah, I wonder what leads Klausner to suppose that this was an unpopular idea at the time when his text was purportedly written...
Mar
3
comment “God looked into the Torah to create the world”
It's found in a range of sources, significantly predating (the publication of) the Zohar, including Tanna deVei Eliyahu and Bereishit Rabbah. I believe the import is that the Torah functions as a type of blueprint.
Mar
3
comment For those that consider Chabad to be heretical, would a woman that received a Get from their Beis Din require another Get?
A link to Rav Shach's speech would be excellent.
Mar
3
answered Recommendation for beginner's Aramaic language book
Mar
2
comment Rabi Yochanan Ben Zakai, or Josephus?
"To assume they are both complete fabrications seems extremely unlikely as well". Really? Why? I can understand why you might have a religious motivation to believe one of them true, but I see no reason as to why, historically, either one of them has to be.
Feb
23
comment Did the Lubavitcher Rebbe ever state why he didn't visit Israel?
I have no source, but I have heard it said that the reason he never gave an explicit reason for not going was so as to not be motzi shem ra on his father-in-law, who visited Palestine (1934) but who left it to live in Poland.
Feb
20
asked Correcting one's father or one's rav when he is leyning
Feb
18
comment Did any of the early Rabbis encounter Mohammed?
Possible dupe? judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/26720/…
Feb
18
answered When in time did the Jewish people get sold to Greacans, according to Joel?
Feb
18
comment Why do people put wine in their pockets at havdalah?
Your comment appears to have answered your own question: "for parnassah and other segulos".