3,344 reputation
1718
bio website
location
age
visits member for 4 years, 5 months
seen 2 hours ago

Feb
26
accepted How did Vashti grow a tail?
Feb
25
comment How did Vashti grow a tail?
@MonicaCellio Yes, I hear what you are saying. Thank you for that. What do you think of the suggested answer I gave below?
Feb
24
comment How did Vashti grow a tail?
@Charles Koppelman Thanks for the Edit!
Feb
24
comment How did Vashti grow a tail?
@MonicaCellio That is an interesting point Monica. Thank you for sharing that. So, you are suggesting that the issue revolves around whether she was punished, and therefore deserved the consequence or the tail just prevented her from listening to Achashveirosh. Perhaps merely to set the stage for Esther, but not necessarily a punishment
Feb
24
comment How did Vashti grow a tail?
Can you elaborate? Perhaps it is a broader discussion then we can have in the comments. I would probably have to show many examples to demonstrate my point.
Feb
24
comment How did Vashti grow a tail?
Thank you for your comments. The comment got cut off, I am curious about what you were going to say. Also, to respond to your comment. She was by nature a prutzah and under normal circumstances would have done this without hesitation as the Gemara indicates. However, the answer of the Tail is suggesting that with the help of the Hashgacha she had a realization that she normally would not have. That is implied by Gavriel. This was out of the ordinary that she was able to see this idea. The Hashgacha helped her to see how she was being perceived so to speak.
Feb
24
comment Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
Thank you. I enjoyed this approach. I gave my own answer below that is similar to your approach, but I added to it.
Feb
24
answered Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
Feb
24
answered How did Vashti grow a tail?
Feb
24
comment How did Vashti grow a tail?
Thank you for sharing those thoughts. My challenge is that when you have two positions in the Gemara, they usually are two different conceptual positions. The way you have described it, they are both the same explanation, her beauty was marred by either a tail or skin affliction. I would think it should be two distinct idea, not just an argument over facts.
Feb
22
asked How did Vashti grow a tail?
Jan
16
comment Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
@Shraga With regard to your comments on thinking for oneself I understand your point.However, I think at times that approach can be taken to an extreme. We must always be careful to be grounded in Torah and our sources. They are the bedrock of our Mesorah. However, one has to be able to be Mechadesh as well. The Torah was given to Man to use his mind to understand it. See the Ibn Ezra on Shemot 20:2. He clearly articulates the need for thoughtful analysis and using ones own mind to understand an area. Certainly our first approach is to see what our Chachamim say, but then it is left to us.
Jan
16
comment Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
@Shraga I hear your question. However, I think that is a different question than I am focusing on. A possible answer for the Rambam might be that Hashem made it happen that way. Hashem thwarted their very predictions, showing that the only true power is Hashem. Maybe it is a Midah Kneged Mida thing. Showing Hashem's involvement. I am not certain of this idea, but it is a different issue than the one I am raising. Assuming according to the Rambam Astrology is fake, what would be the reasoning for the Astrologers for suggesting what they did?
Jan
15
comment Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
@KinnardHockenhull Thank you for your question for clarification. I was referring to the typical supernatural or divine power of prediction often attributed to the astrologers. What I was exploring, is if they had some intelligent plan in making this prediction to Pharoah.
Jan
15
revised Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
I was asked to include a source.
Jan
15
comment Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
@Shraga Thank you for your question. I always grapple with this issue of providing sources versus thinking for oneself. However, since you asked I will respond with a source that supports my premise. I will add the source above in the question.
Jan
15
comment Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
@SethJ Hmm. Thank you for the thoughts. Why would they consider their wizardry to work if they saw that it didn't work. If Hashem did cause a miracle in this instance, how would they know that? Wouldn't they just consider it to be the same as previous tries. Furthermore, if in fact it was a miracle, shouldn't this be reported in the Torah? This is a very interesting area, with lots of questions.
Jan
15
asked Why did the Egyptian “astrologers” tell Pharaoh that a savior would be born?
Jan
15
revised Why did Moshe and Aaron need to use a staff in initiating the plagues?
edited tags
Jan
15
comment Why did Moshe and Aaron need to use a staff in initiating the plagues?
Where is the Sforno that you are referring to? Furthermore, if you look ahead at the other plagues (See Shemot 8:13 by Kinim) he used the staff.