14,786 reputation
2548
bio website
location
age
visits member for 3 years
seen 7 hours ago

1d
comment Authorship of Mishna
@sabbahillel ,according to the Rambam in his hakdama in the Mishna Torah he writes that Rebbi wrote (chibur)
1d
comment Authorship of Mishna
It's a machlokes Rashi and the Rambam
2d
comment Tashlumin for a woman who usually doesn't daven
It is hard to bring all the shittos in a comment but the Magen Avraham reads the Mechaber that a women is required only a short prayer per the Ramabam,even if you want to say that shmoneh esrei is required by both ,there is a difference since if one has time only to follow the Rambam idea of dorasia then maybe a tashlumin is not necessary, but the Ramban holds that tefilla is only a derabbanan from an asmachta.
2d
comment Tashlumin for a woman who usually doesn't daven
And the nafka mina would be if a woman is busy she has to fulfill the Rambams opinion at least,so do we say that she needs a tashlumin for the Rambans opinion or she is covered by the opinion of the Rambam,probably have to edit question
2d
comment Tashlumin for a woman who usually doesn't daven
My point was that the Rambam holds a woman fulfills her obligation with shevach hodah and bakasha ,where the Ramban is of the opinion that women need to daven what the Rabbann set forth
2d
comment Tashlumin for a woman who usually doesn't daven
Since a woman follows the Rambam in this case she has satisfied her obligation of prayer in a sense so maybe she doesn't need to but on the other hand lechatchila she should follow the Ramban
2d
asked Tashlumin for a woman who usually doesn't daven
Apr
29
comment Eating a fish underwater
@shmuel Brin , was just noting the taos sofer,Rav Saadia is quoted as saying a dead fish found in water is assur,but it's the opposite he held eating them alive is assur but dead one can
Apr
28
comment Eating a fish underwater
Rav Saadia Gaon holds that dead fish are assur
Apr
28
comment Eating a fish underwater
Great answer,thanks
Apr
28
accepted Eating a fish underwater
Apr
28
comment Kids waiting between meat and milk
The Be'er Moshe does,will look it up later hopefully.
Apr
28
asked Eating a fish underwater
Apr
28
comment Is it kosher to eat live fish
See the Simla Chadasha which holds that if one washed it very well that it is not disgusting one can eat it
Apr
22
comment Is Transcendental Meditation kosher?
Ask Rabbi Gutman Locks m.youtube.com/user/gutmanlocks
Apr
20
awarded  Revival
Apr
18
awarded  Yearling
Apr
8
answered Potty in the living room?
Apr
3
comment Does a b'chor need to fast if he didn't partake in food from the siyum?
See the piskei tshuvos who will confirm this
Apr
3
comment Bal Tashchit and Chametz
If one holds that one should not sell chametz gamur then they should make a chesbon to try to finish all their chmatez beforehand,