meta user
network profile
| bio | website | kicong.org |
|---|---|---|
| location | Birmingham, AL | |
| age | 31 | |
| visits | member for | 1 year, 9 months |
| seen | Apr 3 at 14:12 | |
| stats | profile views | 48 |
|
Mar 18 |
comment |
Glow sticks on Shabbos Makeh B'Patish is the hardest melakha to hammer out (pun intended). The gemara describes Rebbi Akiva I believe stting and categorizing all the melakhot and anything without a category got put into makeh b'patish. The simple answer is that it isnt M"Bp (makeh bi patish) because it is the designated use of the item not the creating of the item. It would be like saying that unfolding a pair of glasses is M"Bp or that closing the front door of a house is M"Bp it is normal use. Rav Moshe Feinstein paskens that if you have a shirt with detachable sleaves you can attach the sleeves on shabbat. |
|
Mar 18 |
answered | Product of Melachah that wasn't really necessary, except that in the end it was |
|
Mar 18 |
comment |
How exactly was extinguishing used constructively to build the Mishkan/Tabernacle? this is evident from the mishnah in second chapter of shabbat which says that if you extinguish a candle you have transgressed because it creates pekham ash or coals. It is also described as the process called "hivhuv" they would spin the wicks and then cinge the tip to enable easier lighting (mishna shabbat chapter 2) |
|
Mar 18 |
awarded | Supporter |
|
Mar 18 |
awarded | Editor |
|
Mar 18 |
comment |
Glow sticks on Shabbos alright, I added some sources and svarot, I hope this helps. |
|
Mar 18 |
revised |
Glow sticks on Shabbos added sources and svarot (reasoning) the a previous statement. |
|
Mar 18 |
answered | Glow sticks on Shabbos |
|
Aug 2 |
answered | How do married women whose professions are physically demanding cover their hair? |
