3,938 reputation
929
bio website
location
age
visits member for 2 years, 11 months
seen Jul 11 at 13:32

Dec
20
comment Should anyone be burned to death?
@RonMaimon you must not realize that what you are saying here is the very definition of apikorsus. It is prohibited even for a goy to speak this way about G-d.
Dec
2
comment Was Marcus Jastrow an apikores?
What did he have in mind with number 15, I wonder?
Nov
29
comment Do Jewish people believe in God?
@SSpoke, with respect, is English your first language? I ask because there seems to be some loss in translation, as it is impossible to comprehend that any Jew would claim to pray to the Torah, or that rabbis are descendants of G-d. It might help us to know too your cultural and religious background, as it seems that you are perhaps bringing assumptions from non-Jewish culture. By the way, yes, Judaism mandates a belief in G-d.
Nov
27
comment Why do men or boys have to cover their hair, but not unmarried women?
I was with you until "Yeminite customs are some of the most ancient and unchanged from Biblical times". Source for this statement?
Nov
27
comment Variable pronunciation of patach chataf in Lithuanian Hebrew
@DoubleAA for the record, I'm not interested in perfectly replicating any particular havara, I'm just interested in havaros in general, how they formed, and what their rules, whether deliberate or natural, are. Also, to answer your comment prior to your edit, Breslov doesn't have any particular pronunciation. :)
Nov
27
comment Variable pronunciation of patach chataf in Lithuanian Hebrew
@DoubleAA there aren't any sources that discuss pronunciation? Really?
Nov
27
comment Variable pronunciation of patach chataf in Lithuanian Hebrew
@Efraim that sounds right to me, now I wonder if there's any source that spells it out.
Nov
8
comment Minhag of married women shaving during marriage
@DoubleAA when it's not supported by Chazal, it is.
Oct
31
comment Minhag of married women shaving during marriage
@ShmuelBrin on the contrary, he speculates that the Torah sees it as a bad thing.
Oct
23
comment “If you have time, say this”
I agree with @DoubleAA - it's clear that there is a distinction being made between these parshiyos and the rest of korbonos, so it seems to me that there is more at work here than the basic rule of what one skips to keep up with the congregation.
Oct
15
comment Explaining to children why we don't celebrate Halloween
Did the kids celebrate xmas in the past? If not (or if so and no longer), maybe an analogy there... it's a non-Jewish holiday. "We used to celebrate this non-Jewish holiday, but this year we're not going to".
Oct
14
comment Why is semicha specifically to ordain a Rabbi to give psak?
Did Rav Elyashiv ztzl never pasken on kashrus?
Oct
14
comment Is the Koren Sacks Nusach Sefard truly nusach ha'Ari?
This siddur has the kavanos from the Arizal, but I don't think the nusach reflects the Arizal per se. Ultimately I agree with @CharlesKoppelman that the way to "daven nusach Arizal" is to study Kabbalah with a qualified teacher.
Oct
14
comment Is the Koren Sacks Nusach Sefard truly nusach ha'Ari?
There are siddurim which at least intend to be as close as possible to the nusach of the Arizal, but in general Nusach Sefard and Nusach Ari (Chabad) siddurim are not that. In fact, in the case of the latter, the Baal Hatanya explicitly combined a variety of nusachos to make one that he felt was best according to kabbalah, but which does not reflect the exact nusach used by the Arizal. I might recommend offhand Sidur Chemdas Yisroel which at least comes very close.
Oct
14
comment How does Judaism reconcile God cannot be seen/incarnate/etc. with Pilar of Fire story?
What is your basis for asserting that G-d "can show up as pillar of fire"? That does not reflect a plain reading of the text, which states "in a pillar", not "as a pillar". Is your question more about whether or not G-d could have a specific location?
Oct
9
comment Niddah and Counting 7 Clean Days - What are its Origins?
@DoubleAA from the question: "How and why did this go from being a widespread personal chumra to being codified halacha?" As for SE policy, would you be so kind as to link me to it? It seems to me that a question asked solely to push an agenda is simply not a good question, although I guess I ought to dan lechaf zechus.
Oct
8
comment Niddah and Counting 7 Clean Days - What are its Origins?
For the record, I think this question could be improved if it was more generalized. How widespread and universal chumros become Halacha is an interesting question in general.
Oct
8
comment Niddah and Counting 7 Clean Days - What are its Origins?
@DoubleAA it's not the best analogy - as I said, this is a matter of Halacha. I'll admit I skipped the Rambam, but having read it, where does it say it was a personal chumra? It seems to me to read that it was a widespread universal chumra. As for downvoting vs answering, it is my general policy to downvote large groups of "agenda" questions, especially those that are basically arguing against Halacha. You are entitled to employ a different approach.
Oct
8
comment Niddah and Counting 7 Clean Days - What are its Origins?
Your recent edit makes the question even more confusing because you are asking about exactly that about which you say you are not asking.
Oct
8
comment Niddah and Counting 7 Clean Days - What are its Origins?
Personally, I downvoted because the whole question is based upon a faulty premise - namely that the Halacha you are describing was ever literally a personal chumra. It seems to me that it is correctly understand as a widespread chumra to the point that it is universal. A corollary might be lighting Shabbos candles 18 minutes early, except I'm not sure that that's actually Halacha, whereas counting seven clean days is.