Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I had heard of something relating to melacha on Shabbat from an (orthodox!) rabbi who mentioned something really interesting. At a certain level of removal, one can indirectly perform melacha. It was something to the effect of a rube goldberg action wherein one starts one reaction which isn't melacha which in turn starts another reaction which isn't melacha which starts another reaction which isn't melacha which, finally, starts a reaction that is melacha, and somehow this is kosher.

I suppose the premise is that at a certain level, it's not guaranteed that you're doing something and something in the multiple reactions could fail, so it removes you a certain distance which makes it extremely unlikely for you to break Shabbat or Yom Tov. I've also heard of this applying to kosher ovens which can be turned on during Shabbat or Yom Tov as well as wheelchairs and certain motion-sensing cameras. What is the actual halacha of this and does it really apply as above (by a certain level of removal from the prohibited act)?

share|improve this question
This is a fascinating, yet incredibly complex area of halacha, that applies not only to Shabbat, but to most any action intended to perform a mitzva or violate one. – jake Jun 21 '11 at 23:20
up vote 8 down vote accepted

It's known as grama, or "indirect causation."

It was written up well in a Journal of Halacha & Contemporary Society article many years ago, I believe as:

Rabbi Tzvi Sendler, Gramma in Halacha, XXXIX, 23

(And Jake, it's not as clear that the same concept would apply to other mitzvahs; the threshold for Sabbath-prohibited labor is higher because it must be melechet machshevet, "concentrated labor.")

One way to accomplish grama involves a five-second delay between your action and the result (well maybe a bit less than five seconds, long enough to say "Greetings and blessings, my dear teacher and master!"). This is employed by Rabbi Moshe Heinemann in Sabbath-mode ovens, which may have their temperature adjusted on holidays (but not Shabbat).

Many other grama devices are available in Israel; I'd heard of a patrol car that had grama mode for normal patrol, but then could be switched to ordinary mode if there was an emergency.

There's even talk of things like a grama light switch (the switch doesn't turn the light on, it just removes something that had been keeping the light off), though regardless of the internal mechanism, you could argue that a push-button reaction is no longer "indirect." I heard from Rabbi Herschel Welcher that Israeli halachic authorities are more inclined towards allowing grama switches; American rabbis aren't, but in America it's easy to find a non-Jew handy who can turn on/off the light.

share|improve this answer
do you have a link or title to the Journal of Halacha & Contemporary Society article? – Menachem Jun 22 '11 at 5:08
@Menachem, jlaw.com/About/jhcs.html has information about the journal. it's not online AFAICT. – msh210 Jun 22 '11 at 15:36
@msh210: If we know the name of the article, we may be able to find it online. Many 3rd party sites have various articles from the journal on their website, like this one on vegetarianism: download.yutorah.org/1981/1053/735657.pdf – Menachem Jun 22 '11 at 18:43
Awesome! Where can I learn more on this complicated area of halacha? – Naftuli Tzvi Kay Jun 23 '11 at 19:07

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.