Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In Ashkenazik circles, can a child be named similar to a living grandparent?
How close is too close?

Examples:

David & Davida
Mira & Meira
Chana & Chanan
Gila & Gilaad
Misha & Moshe
Bella & Beila
Eli & Eliezer

EDIT:

My question is really: can the names sound alike? or is more about meaning of the name?

share|improve this question
    
I think Eli & Eliezer is the same name. –  user6781 Jul 24 at 14:26
    
@user6781 Unless it's Eliana or some other female-specific name that starts with "Eli" ....if you follow the pattern, it seems that all the names are male-female pairs, in which case this question is relateld but not duplicate. –  Shokhet Jul 24 at 15:03
    
Simcha -- maybe that should be clarified by editing if my guess is correct. –  Shokhet Jul 24 at 15:04
    
Also related: judaism.stackexchange.com/q/12906/5323 (but again, neither duplicate if the question is "naming kids after living relatives of the opposite gender") –  Shokhet Jul 24 at 15:06
    
@user6781 - I can't say about current "name practice", but "Eli" and "Eliezer" where originally, 2 different people. Eli was the Kohen who "watched" Shmu'el and Eliezer was Avraham's servant. –  DanF Jul 24 at 15:24

2 Answers 2

up vote 1 down vote accepted

Maaseh shehaya. My chavrusa who's wife's name is Faigel wanted to name his daughter Faiga. Now, the Aruch Hashulchan already said they are two different names, Faigel which means bird in Yiddish and Faiga which is a fig. My chavrusa asked me to pose his situation to Reb Dovid Feinstein who I was going to see. Reb Dovid said not to name the child a similar name. He said the reason we don't name the same name is because of ayin haraa and by the time people figure out that they are actually two different names it will be too late, the damage done by the initial shock will be irreversible.

share|improve this answer
    
What ayin hara applies to similar names? –  Double AA Jul 24 at 17:29
    
Apparently thats the reason we don't do it. Should i rhetorically ask what ayin hara applies when two brothers get aliyos one after another. –  user6591 Jul 24 at 17:53
    
@user6591 - "Should i rhetorically ask what ayin hara applies when two brothers get aliyos one after another. " You can't, because I'll give you an answer that my son told me ... "He looked at me funny!" –  DanF Jul 24 at 18:13
    
Thank you this answered my question. –  Simcha Jul 24 at 21:04
    
Glad it helped. –  user6591 Jul 24 at 22:59

I personally know of an Ashkenazi father whose name is Eliezer and his sons name is Elozor. I believe these people follow Halacha. So I conclude that according to at least one as yet unknown Halachic authority there is no Halachic issue so long the name is different.

share|improve this answer
1  
Do you have any reason to think these people are Halachik authorities or do you know upon whose Halachik ruling they relied? –  Double AA Jul 24 at 15:32
    
These are people that follow Halacha, and I am certain they asked. –  Gershon Gold Jul 24 at 15:36
    
Are they Ashkenazi? –  Double AA Jul 24 at 15:42
    
Yes they are Ashkenazi. –  Gershon Gold Jul 24 at 15:42

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.