Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Is there anything wrong with celebrating Father's Day? (Perhaps implying that you only need to give your father special attention one day a year?)

Is there anything right with celebrating Father's Day? (Perhaps ensures that at least one day a year you will give your father special attention?)

Do any contemporary poskim discuss this?

share|improve this question
    
And chukas hagoyim is not part of your question? –  Nafkamina Jun 16 at 21:02
    
@Nafkamina I left it open-ended and offered one possibility for each side. If you can find idolatrous roots for Father's day, or some other reason it should be a problem, fire away. –  YeZ Jun 16 at 21:04
    
I assume this question goes for mothers' day as well? –  bondonk Jun 16 at 21:10
    
Kibbud Av v'Em is not restricted to one day! –  bondonk Jun 16 at 21:10
3  
In Israel they have "Yom Aim" (Mother's Day), but they also have Chodesh Av. –  sabbahillel Jun 16 at 22:43

1 Answer 1

Will Rogers commented on Mother's Day:

It's a nice idea and all, but whoever came up with it must have had a hurting conscience.

I can't see Father's Day as having blatantly pagan origins. If having one day a year to focus on recognizing your father is meaningful for your father (especially if he's expecting some recognition), then by all means do it. If neither he nor you really cares about it, then there's no need.

Look, today we like to turn values into simple actions that can be ceremonialized and commercialized. You bought dad a plasma TV on Father's Day? Yotzei. The true meaning of honoring your parents is complex; the medrish says that you could feed your elderly father the finest of aged steaks while dishonoring him ("it's food dad, just eat it, old man. I've got take this phone call now."); or give him heavy labor at the millstone while honoring him ("between the two of us, one needed to work the mill, and the other needed to be drafted into the army; I'm so sorry dad, I think this is the least-difficult thing I could do to you.") It's all about the attitude.

And from the father's perspective, well, Judaism expects men to civilize themselves and shoulder the responsibility of being an involved parent. If it makes you feel better that there's one day a year when everyone publicly gives you a salute for it, then fine. Hey the Talmud says you don't always have to have perfect motivations for doing the right thing.

I'll tell you how I was taught to observe Father's Day: my father would remind me to call my grandfather (his father) and wish him a Happy Father's Day.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.