Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Usually, around Mother's Day and Valentines Day, I hear a radio commercial suggesting that, as a gift to your loved one, you can name a star after him / her. (Amazing gimmick - no inventory!!)

In reading Torah Temimah's explanation on this verse "G-d counts the number of the stars and calls each by name",

שהקב"ה קורא לכולם בדבור אחד ולכל אחד  ואחד בשמו המיוחד לו, וכל השמות כוללם בדבור אחד, וכל כוכב וכוכב שומע שמו כשקורא אותם הקב"ה

(Loose translation) - "G-d calls out to all of them in one calling and to each one in its specified name..."

it seems to imply that God has already assigned a name to each star. The ad implies that the star has never been named, previously. So, if I have my name registered with the notion that the star has never been previously named, am I not denyong what God has already done?

share|improve this question
3  
God calls it a סוס but I call it a horse. What's the problem? –  Double AA May 15 at 18:48
1  
Do you know all of God's names for the stars? Maybe the name you give it happens to be the name God calls it. ; Why don't you consider your name to be a nickname? ; God created light. Does that mean that everytime I turn on my lamp I am somehow impinging on God? ; Finally, the Gemara clearly refers to stars by their Greek names. if they can do it, so can you. –  Shmuel May 15 at 20:15
1  
@Shmu'el - place an answer, please. Your reasoning sounds credible. Please include location of the Gemarrah ref. –  DanF May 15 at 21:10
    
Berachot 58b, Pesachim 94, Shabbat 156a, ERUVIN 56. This article lists more places, but those are the one's I've checked and confirmed. –  Shmuel May 16 at 4:59
    
See also Job 38:31-32 –  Shmuel May 16 at 5:07

1 Answer 1

I may expand on this answer later, but the short version is: No, the verse does not imply that, and no, you are not denying anything God has done.

  • We don't learn halacha from poetry in Tehillim.
  • That verse isn't implying anything about the stars or their names, other than God is so great that He can name all the stars.
  • Names are subjective, not objective.
  • Just because God does something doesn't mean you can't do it also.
  • A person's actions cannot impinge on God's glory or ability.

citation needed

share|improve this answer
    
And, from a hashkafic perspective, maybe we should stop looking in Torah for things we can't do and start looking for positive things that we can do. –  Shmuel May 19 at 0:27
1  
The first point isn't completely true. The Gemara often leans halachos from random pesukim in Nach. –  Ypnypn May 19 at 1:10

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.