Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Both Jews and Noahides are forbidden to eat aiver min hachai (a limb torn from a live animal).

Is there any difference between the prohibitions for Jews and non-Jews?

share|improve this question
add comment

1 Answer 1

up vote 5 down vote accepted

Yes there are many differences.


  • Jews are allowed to eat pieces taken from the animal immediately after shechita is performed, even while the animal is still moving מפרכס (blood must still be removed -- which is harder to do compared to regular meat, because it was taken alive-ish). Shechita kills the animal, even if it is still convulsing. (Simla Chadasha 27:1)
    Before digging in, one should wait until the animal stops moving, which is possibly a biblical prohibition of לא תאכלו על הדם (literally, "do not eat on the blood").

  • However, a Noahide has to wait until the animal stops moving in order to be allowed to eat it (27:2).

This leads to an interesting paradox -- after an animal was killed, while it is still moving, it is permitted to Jews and forbidden to non-Jews.
Therefore, based on the principle "ליכא מידי דלישראל מותר ולעכו"ם אסור" ("there is nothing that is permitted to Jews but forbidden to non-Jews") the convulsing animal would be permitted to Noahides if it's a kosher animal that had a good shechita (i.e. not neveila) and was killed by a Jew, even though it would be forbidden if a non-Jew killed it. (ibid., Shach 27:2)


Rambam (Melachim 9:10) also says that while a Jew is only culpable for a shiur (kezayis) of eiver min hachai, the non-Jew is culpable for any amount of eiver min hachai. (see later in this answer for more from the Rambam on this topic)


Chasam Sofer (Tshuva 19, brought by Pischei Tshuva 62:1) says that since eggs are really eiver min hachai (see this answer), and only became מותר to Jews from a דרשה in a פסוק, since the non-Jews never got the Torah, they never got the allowance to eat eggs. Now, because of ליכא מידי, eggs that Jews are allowed to eat are also permitted to non-Jews [ignoring the רמב"ם, who doesn't hold of ליכא מידי (he writes that even if a Jew killed it, it would still be forbidden to non-Jews), and therefore all would be אסור].

However, this means that those eggs that are not לישראל מותר, would still be forbidden to non-Jews. This includes ביצי טריפה [the eggs of kosher animals that have certain bodily defects such as torn lung, broken leg/wing in certain locations etc.], and ביצי טמאה [non-kosher animals, such as hawks or snakes] (those are his examples, I would add the eggs of a chicken that you hit, that is eiver min hachai [see here again], as well as fertilized eggs [the ones with blood spots]).
These eggs may not be sold to גויים by Jews due to לפני עור, but since eggs are common מצוי it's fine. All the same, they should not be gifted freely, unless there is room to say that they will be used for a non-food purpose, such as for glue or to be incubated/raised by his chickens. If it is clearly for food, such as if it is already cooked, then it is אסור. If there is a food that was cooked with eggs, it is still אסור, because גויים do not have ביטול, even in 1,000 (see this question, which leaves it unresolved whether or not ביטול may be used for גויים, the Chasam Sofer assumes that it may not), and even if it is a נותן טעם לפגם.

[We do not פסקן like the Rambam that does not hold of ליכא מידי due to the Simla Chadasha mentioned above, but all the same, according to Chasam Sofer one would not be allowed to sell ביצי טריפה\טמאה, and one might argue that when he is the only egg vendor (=not מצוי) it would be אסור as well]


Credit for the Rambam, Shach and Chasam Sofer go to Yoni. Thanks! :)

share|improve this answer
    
Isn't there another difference regarding a nonkosher animal (like a horse or pig)? And things that are yotzai min hachai? –  Yoni May 14 at 5:01
    
@Yoni Could be....I don't know...care to fill me in and I'll add it to the answer? –  Shokhet May 14 at 5:02
    
Look in hilchis ever min hachai or rambam melachim..I'll see what I can so tomorrow. –  Yoni May 14 at 5:05
    
@Yoni Will do...thanks! –  Shokhet May 14 at 5:05
1  
I think this was the diba raah that yosef brought to yaakov. the brothers held ever min hachai was permitted after shechita and yosef held only after it stopped moving. given that they were noachides at the time, it seems yosef was right in rebuking them. –  ray May 14 at 6:28
show 8 more comments

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.