Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

There have been instances where we had 9 people in the shul, and we began to daven Mincha Shabbat afternoon. We finished our individual Shmoneh Esreh, when the 10th person appeared. Can we go back and read the Torah, or since we are past that point in the service, we cannot do so?

share|improve this question
    
This has been the custom in every synagogue I've ever been in. –  Tatpurusha May 8 at 16:10
    
@Tatpurusha Which has been the custom you have seen, to go back and read the Torah or not? At my synagogue, if the tenth man walks in during Ashrei on Monday morning, we do not go back. I cannot answer for Shabbat. –  Mike May 8 at 21:59
    
@Mike To go back and read. –  Tatpurusha May 9 at 17:36

2 Answers 2

The mitzvah of reading from the Torah on Shabbos, YomTov and Mondays and Thursdays takes place during tefillah but is not dependent upon it. Certainly the preferable mode of reading from the Torah is during davening but the mitzvah lasts all day and when a minyan is available they should read from Torah. (Mishne Berurah 135:1, Shaar Hatziyun 3 and Aruch Hashulchan 135:6,7, Dagul Mervavah, Mahari Asad 58. However, some maintain that if mincha time has arrived, the Torah should not be read. See Mikraei Kodesh (Grodzinsky), Klal 13:5 and Shaarei Kedusha 10,11)

Years ago I spent my afternoons in a kosher slaughterhouse and the shochtim started working before sunrise and continued until noon with breaks after their hourly shifts. They were unable to form a minyan when they davened Shachris but, during lunch hour, when all the shochtim were off duty and could form a minyan, they read from the Torah.

share|improve this answer

I checked with my LOR and he said that if someone makes the minyon after everyone else has davened, he can say borchu, shmoneh esrai with haiche kedusha, and the minyon can lain. The reason for this is that since a minyon is present, he can daven with what must be said in the presence of a minyon even though nobody else is davening. I am deliberately not dealing with duchening (for those whose minhag is to duchen every day) as I do not have the sources available or the time to go into it. My LOR did not discuss that case. The main question is leining if the tenth person comes after everyone else has finished davening (especially Shabbos Mincha when shmoneh esrai follows leining). Duchening does not apply for Shabbos Mincha in any case.

Logic might seem to indicate that if everyone else can stay and no kohen has had kiddush (which would prevent the kohanim from duchening) then the kohanim should be able to go in front of the aron and duchen (during Shacharis). However, this is logic only based on the idea that a kohen who has davened already can duchen at a different minyon. I have not seen this explicitly in the various sources that I have read, but I have not seen anything to refute it either. This is the same logic that allows the Torah to be read at a separate time.

share|improve this answer
    
By that logic why can't he Duchen? –  Double AA May 9 at 2:46
    
@DoubleAA I would suppose that he could, but I did not think to ask that. I just asked about regular weekday and Shabbos. –  sabbahillel May 9 at 3:21
    
Duchening is regular weekday and twice on Shabbos. –  Double AA May 9 at 3:21
    
@DoubleAA The question is only in Eretz Yisrael and I did not ask it. That would be a question for a rav in Eretz Yisroel in the area where kohanim duchen every day. As I said, I do not think that was part of the original question. You should ask the OP where he is talking about. –  sabbahillel May 9 at 13:40
    
The question is for all congregations which Duchen daily, of which there are many in Chu"l as well. The question is for any rav who can paskin independent of where he lives. It doesn't really matter what the OP was thinking or not, as we are not issuing psak to him. Sometimes I feel you don't understand how this site works... –  Double AA May 9 at 16:53

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.