Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I've looked on the websites and, other than just going in and asking each and every local synagogue, is there some easy way to know if an orthodox synagogue is Modern or Traditional?

share|improve this question
2  
You may wish to look at the "About the Rabbi" section, where the yeshiva that the rabbi attended (and therefore his likely philosophical bent) would be listed. The distinction in practice between Modern Orthodox and Centrist Orthodox is often kind of fuzzy; a Haredi synagogue probably wouldn't have a website. –  Tatpurusha May 5 at 23:30
1  
@Tatpurusha Although these labels are not generally well defined (or else they are defined in many different ways by different people), the neologism "Centrist Orthodox" is usually self-applied to people who would traditionally be considered "Modern Orthodox." –  Fred May 6 at 0:16
1  
neither "Orthodox" nor "Modern Orthodox" is defined and quantified to the exclusion of the other so there is no official affiliation that a synagogue might have. A synagogues association with the RCA or the Young Israel or the Agudah tells about some of the synagogue's official religious positions but says nothing about the people who happen to attend. Maybe if you defined the terms as you understand them, someone might be able to find a link which will make your definitions fruitful in anticipating a shul's place on the continuum. –  Danno May 6 at 2:56
2  
Those aren't the only two options within orthodoxy. Do you mean to ask "how do I know what flavor of orthodox?" or are you asking specifically about these two? And if the latter, what does "Traditional" mean -- all of them would presumably say they're traditional, right? –  Monica Cellio May 6 at 14:51
2  
Close as Unclear? You can't answer a question about undefined terms. –  Double AA May 6 at 18:39

3 Answers 3

up vote 5 down vote accepted

The question mistakenly assumes that every Orthodox synagogue is either Modern Orthodox or not. This is not the case.

  1. The MO and charedim mix to a large extent. There are shuls with a charedi rabbi but a mainly MO congregation, and there are many shuls with a mix of charedi and MO congregants.

  2. Many people are in between MO and charedi. They might describe themselves as "frum but not yeshivish" or "centrist Orthodox" or just "Orthodox" or "frum." The men will often wear black kippas, typically velvet, but not black hats, and will wear colored as well as white shirts. Other people may "look" charedi but have a more MO hashkafa or halachic orientation, and vice versa.

Accordingly, I'll answer the question by noting separately how you can determine whether the rabbi and congregation are MO or charedi.

To determine whether the rabbi is MO or charedi, look at his bio. Did he go to YU, and does he belong to the RCA? Then he is probably Centrist or Modern Orthodox. Did he go to YCT? Then he is Modern and/or Open Orthodox. Did he go to a charedi yeshivah? Then he's charedi.

To determine whether the congregants are MO or charedi, see how they dress. The more knitted and non-black kippas, the fewer beards and especially long beards, the fewer black hats, the more MO the shul is.

share|improve this answer

In America, using an Israeli/Sephardi transliteration (Shacharit as opposed to Shacharis) often indicates that the synagogue is more Modern. The size of the mechitzah is also a clear indicator; the larger and more opaque it is, the more traditional the synagogue. Modern congregations usually sing more of the prayers, so their Shabbat morning prayers are usually longer.

share|improve this answer
    
Haredi Sephardi shuls would use Sephardi pronunciation. –  Daniel May 6 at 19:34
    
@Daniel That's why I wrote "In America" where Ashkenazim greatly outnumber Sephardim, and "often". –  Ypnypn May 6 at 20:09
    
Some Hasidic shuls sing much of the Shabbos service in the evening at least, and prolong prayers. Satmar and Breslov do this. Others, such as Belz and Lubavitch I think, go fast however. Of course, said Hasidic shuls would use different niggunim probably than Young Israel. –  Ploni Almoni May 7 at 2:05

In America:

A high percentage of black hats is a sign that the synagogue is more haredi orthodox than modern orthodox.

A prayer for the state of Israel is a sign that the synagogue is more modern orthodox.

You can also look at the tone of the parsha sheets and listen for the tone in the Rabbi's speeches.

If there are some people who regularly drive to the synagogue on Shabbos, it is almost certainly not a haredi orthodox synagogue.

share|improve this answer
    
Also, look out for the term "Torah Lifestyle" –  Clint Eastwood May 6 at 12:50

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.