Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

We would like to perform a minyan for the deaf. All the participants can speak verbally, but cannot hear, including the Torah reader. Can he sign the words that he is reading during Kri'at Hatorah, or is there a halacha that the Torah must be specifically oralized and only in Hebrew?

share|improve this question
    
ASL or Hebrew sign language? (Not sure if this makes a difference.) Also, looks like three separate questions. 1. Oral/speaking, 2. Hebrew only, 3. Does HSL count as Hebrew? –  Shmuel Apr 28 at 19:27
2  
You should really consult a knowledgeable rabbi for this issue. –  Shmuel Apr 28 at 19:32
    
I don't think it matters, as deaf people aren't obligated in this mitzvah. That being said, I'm still curious as to the halachic status of sign language. –  Avram Levitt Apr 28 at 20:31
    
Is the obligation\mitzvah to "read" or to "hear?" –  Shmuel Apr 29 at 4:47
    
I don't understand the question. the reader is not saying it by heart so what can be wrong with assembling a group of Jewish people to read from the torah? –  ray Apr 29 at 12:31

1 Answer 1

Rabbi Dovid Stein of Beit Kenesset Chatam in Rehovot has a large group of deaf people come and read Parshas Zachor from the torah every year. Meaning that each individual comes to the torah and reads for himself. Presumably this is because "krias hatorah" needs to be just that - reading from the torah, and sign language is not considered to fit into the halachik category of reading.

There are those who say based on the Rambam in Tefila 12:1 that the requirement to read the torah is a requirement of the community, but not of any one specific individual, and therefore if one were to miss some of the reading he does not have to make it up, because he is not individually required to hear it. (This would be in distinction from hearing meggilas Esther on Purim.) If that is the case, the same would hold true for deaf people. They are not individually required to hear the reading, and so it would not be necessary to have the reading signed to them.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.