Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

With few exceptions (days when Tachanun isn't said, possibly on the Four Parshiyot), the prayer Av haRachamim, which talks about "the destruction of the Ashkenazi communities around the Rhine River by Christian crusaders during the First Crusade", is recited on every Shabbat. This prayer does not fit with the joyous theme of Shabbat, and as mentioned in Why are some bakashot made on Shabbat? , "prayers of request (bakashot)" are generally prohibited. Why, then, is this prayer recited every week?

(I could understand if it was recited specifically during the dates when the destruction took place, but every week?)

share|improve this question
    
Do you want a reason (why do we say it every Shabas) or an excuse (how dare we say it every Shabas) or either/both? –  msh210 Apr 27 at 4:10
    
@msh210 What's the difference? –  Shmuel Apr 27 at 7:59
1  
A reason to say it every Shabas might be that the tragedy was so severe that we feel a need to mention it often or that there are more people in the synagogue on Shabas than other days, for example. Those don't excuse saying a somber prayer on Shabas, but they are reasons to do so. An excuse for saying it every Shabas might be that it doesn't count as mourning or that doesn't count as a request, for example. Those aren't reasons to say it, but they excuse saying it. –  msh210 Apr 27 at 15:24
    
That quote from Wikipedia is taken out of context. In its proper context, it indicates when the prayer was enacted, not what it speaks about. –  Double AA Jun 19 at 3:41

1 Answer 1

up vote 4 down vote accepted

In the Rödelheim siddur, Rallis Wiesenthal's Siddur Sefas Yisroel, and the original Commonwealth edition of the Sacks Siddur, the instructions are to say Av Harachamim only on the shabbat before Shavuout and Shabbat Chazon. The custom of saying it every shabbat is, according to the former two, an innovation of Minhag Polin, which might mean that due to the even-worse conditions in Poland, it was necessary to introduce an added note of solemnity for shabbat.

share|improve this answer
1  
A reasonable conjecture. Tach v'Tat, which heavily affected Polish Jews, is linked with the Rhineland massacres of 1096 in one nusach of א-ל מלא רחמים even though the original prayer predates Tach v'Tat. Perhaps Tach v'Tat likewise compounded the importance of Av HaRamchamim for Polish Jews. –  Fred Apr 27 at 5:31

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.