Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

There are differences in 'bug checking strategies' for different countries due to differences in bugs, pesticides, harvesting and packaging techniques (etc.). In Israel, I have recently encountered people who will not eat certain fruits or vegetables (strawberries, figs, cabbage, etc.) which they render 'uncheckable'. I was directed to the reputable kosharot website when trying to check a cabbage:

פוסקי הדור מציינים שבגלל כמה סיבות שונות אין לאדם רגיל (שאין לו הכשרה מיוחדת בבדיקת ירקות עלים) להשתמש בירקות עלים לא מפוקחים ומכונים בפי כל "ירקות גוש קטיף

The decisors of [halacha of this] generation mark that, for a number of different reasons, a regular person (who has no special preparation in checking leaf vegetables) is not to use leaf vegetables not supervised and nicknamed in everyone's speech "Gush Katif vegetables"

I found it strange that some vegetables are 'impossible' to be check for bugs, unless you are an expert. Certainly 'bug problems' now are no worse than the situations that our ancestors encountered. Why, nowadays, would some things be forbidden on the grounds that some bugs are impossible to be found/removed? Perhaps I am naive in thinking that all vegetables/fruits were eaten in the past as long as they were checked - perhaps they weren't, for this reason. If anyone can shed light on this it would be most appreciated.

(As an aside I went on a tiyul in Israel where our tour guide pointed out a hefker fig tree, picked a fig, opened it, spent time checking it and ate it. Another member of the tour said that his Rosh Yeshiva forbids eating figs because they cannot be checked. How is it possible that one of the shiv'at ha'minim are impossible to check and therefore inedible?!)

share|improve this question
    
There are those who hold strawberries cannot be checked,regarding how can the shivim minim are not be checked has to do with infestation which is not always constant ,its a come any go type thing . –  sam Apr 27 at 1:18
    

2 Answers 2

I actually had lunch with a mashgiach over Shabbos. I can't cite all of his sources, but we actually discussed this and he told me the following:

Because of environmental and health concerns, the pesticides we use are much more benign than those used as little as 25 years ago. We have infestations that would be simple to get rid of, but we don't.

Because of globalization, pests that used to only live in some countries are now all over the world, so there are many more pests that can occupy any given vegetable than there were in previous generations.

The Ohr HaChaim actually says that bug populations are inversely proportional with the spiritual state of the world, and "creepy crawly things" increase as our spiritual levels plummet. In a society which has allowed homosexual relationships, done away with laws of modesty, excuses (to put it nicely) abortion, and essentially allows adultery, it should be no surprise that bug infestations have increased.

As an aside, Chayei Adam in his explanation of the Yom Kippur viduy says that (in his time) the issur of eating bugs is almost unavoidable due to the difficulty of checking (see his entry for ashamnu).

share|improve this answer
    
Some of the examples you bring are quite subjective. Rape, paedophilia, homosexuality, polygamy, avodah zara, torture (etc.) according to many accounts used to be more prevalent. I don't think the examples you brought make 'nowadays' much worse than earlier times. Rape and homosexuality in ancient Rome, for instance, was rife. Plus, it is hard to know the extent of the ill practices of the past. –  bondonk Jun 2 at 20:58
    
@bondonk I'm not going to bother arguing the point, but it is fairly commonly accepted that the morals of our society have plummeted. I don't think homosexual marriage was ever condoned or acknowledged as legitimate before this generation. –  YEZ Jun 2 at 21:01
    
@bondonk and since when is polygamy bad? I was referring to extramarital. –  YEZ Jun 2 at 21:01
    
@ YEZ I guess I am challenging a common accepted fact! I would assume the Rabbinic ban on polygamy nowadays means it is not a positive thing. I agree on the extramarital. Who is to say that it is worse now? I would imagine that modern media promulgates many practices now that were previously hidden. Homosexuality of men with boys in ancient Greece and Rome was positively practiced, open and defined a man's status in society. There are countless examples. –  bondonk Jun 2 at 21:11
    
it could even be argued that we are in the best state that the Jewish people have been for a while. There are more people free to learn Torah. Boys and girls going to Yeshiva and Seminary. Countless Kollelim worldwide, etc. –  bondonk Jun 2 at 21:13

I heard in the name of Rav Yisrael Belsky that in the past our bubbes and zeidies all has a tradition as to how to check the vast majority of fruits and vegetables the were in common use. With the advent of pesticides many people were of the opinion that the fruits and vegetables no longer needed to be checked, and the traditions of how to check were lost. When in the relatively recent past it has been discovered that many fruits and vegetables formally thought to be bug free are actually bug-ridden, such as cabbage, strawberries etc. there was no longer a common tradition as to how to check them, and we did not grow up with the awareness of the bugs that we need to look for. As a result there are those that say that these fruits and vegetables are no longer able to be checked by untrained eyes.

I can tell you from personal experience that checking a fig is extremely difficult. I was shown by someone who knows how to check them how similar the worms that infest them look to the seeds, and how without knowing what to look for it would be very easy to overlook them, thinking they are just another seed.

share|improve this answer
    
Does he give an approximate date for when this tradition was lost? –  Double AA Apr 27 at 7:22
    
@DoubleAA I don't know –  Jewels Apr 27 at 7:41
    
So if my grandmother always checked, and taught my mother then I still have the common tradition. –  Gershon Gold Apr 28 at 14:03
    
Interesting. However on the OU website the following is quoted. "Engaging in what he termed “demystifying the process of checking vegetables and fruits,” Rabbi Steinberg declared that contrary to popular belief, “it’s not impossible to do". I guess perhaps Rabbi Steinberg disagrees with Rabbi Belsky? –  Gershon Gold Apr 29 at 15:32

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.