Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In most states, certain food items are taxable. For example, in NY, sales tax is charged on soda, wine and beer. If this is included in the sale of my chametz, and I don't charge the buyer tax, I may be breaking the law. Would that invalidate the sale?

share|improve this question
    
In all states when you return a purchase, the amount you paid for sales tax is returned. Thus this question is purely hypothetical. –  Gershon Gold Apr 7 at 17:41
    
@GershonGold Why hypothetical? What if it doesn't get returned? Also, wouldn't this still be a problem from the outset? –  Double AA Apr 7 at 18:03
1  
There are two answers so far disputing the premise, saying that you don't owe sales tax so it's fine. Are you asking about NY (and if that tax doesn't apply, all well and good), or about a case where sales tax is due and you didn't pay it? And you're asking about the halacha, not secular law, right? –  Monica Cellio Apr 7 at 19:09
    
Before we get bogged down on the issue of taxes invalidating the sale, it would probably be of use to demonstrate in the body of your question that resales are included in the tax laws. If you hold a garage sale, for example, do you have to pay (and/or charge) sales tax? –  Seth J Apr 7 at 21:12
1  
I should note that my LOR just explained that when you buy back the Chametz after Pesach, it is not a return but an actual sale. If it were a return, then it would invalidate the original sale and you would be liable for owning chametz on Pesach. It is only because the rav actually goes to the goy and arranges to buy it back that the whole situation is legal according to halacha. My rav explained that he actually only borrows it from the goy right after Pesach because he cannot buy it back until after Pesach is over for the farthest west (such as California while he is on the east coast) –  sabbahillel Apr 8 at 2:45

5 Answers 5

Per here as long as you sell the item from your home, and don't deliver it (and several other limitations) you do not have to pay sales tax. If you happen to sell more than $600 worth, but didn't intend to, then you have to pay taxes on the rest. But that is only true after the fact, so you don't have to register.

So the upshot is that since you don't expect to owe sales tax on more than $600, the general case of the individual selling Chametz is not a problem.

Businesses, however, may face other complications, as they don't fall under the same exemption.

By the way, you are under no obligation to charge the buyer the tax. You (the seller) just have to pay it.

share|improve this answer

Other answerers have disputed your premise that you'd need, under the law, to worry about sales tax. I'll grant arguendo that there's a sales-tax issue but dispute another premise: that you need to charge your gentile customer the sales tax. Stores frequently have "we'll pay the tax!" sales. That is, instead of charging you $108 for a $100 item and forwarding $8 (for example) to the government, they charge you $100 only; they then forward $7.41 to the government, because 8% tax on $100−$7.41=$92.59 is $7.41. But it's not only for special sales that stores do this: every time they make a sale, they later forward about 7.41% of the money to the government. And they do it every so often, not after every sale. You're effectively doing the same with the non-Jew: you are selling him chametz and later will forward about 7.41% of the sale price to the government.[1] If you wind up not doing so, that's an issue later between you and the government, and has nothing to do with the validity of the sale. (No source for that last half-sentence of my answer, but it seems obvious to me.)


[1] Again, that's assuming you need to.

share|improve this answer
    
Hasn't Yishai already made this point? –  Double AA Apr 8 at 4:21
    
@DoubleAA he is making the point that even if Yishai is not correct (but he is correct) the seller would still not have to charge the buyer sales tax. The sales tax would be a separate operation between the seller and the government and would not invalidate the sale (if not sent to the government). –  sabbahillel Apr 8 at 13:42
    
@DoubleAA, perhaps he alluded to it in his last paragraph; certainly I stated it more fully. –  msh210 Apr 8 at 14:40

The sales tax has already been applied when you bought the food from the store to begin with. Reselling it to a goy (and back) does not incur tax unless you "add value" somehow.

share|improve this answer
1  
I don't think this is true. In the US, you don't have a VAT tax, you have a sales tax. As such, you may be entitled to a refund on the sales tax you paid to buy it when you resell it, but "adding value" is of no relevance. –  Yishai Apr 7 at 18:30
    
I thought VAT and sales tax are the same thing. –  Clint Eastwood Apr 7 at 18:32
    
See here among others tax.thomsonreuters.com/blog/onesource/indirect-tax/… –  Yishai Apr 7 at 18:34

It would seem to me that in the state on NJ this would be considered a "casual sale" and would not be subject to tax.

http://www.state.nj.us/treasury/taxation/pdf/pubs/sales/anj15.pdf

Under :Seasonal, Occasional, and Casual Sales

Sales by persons making isolated or occasional sales of items of tangible personal property which were purchased by them for their own use are considered to be “casual sales” and are not subject to tax. Examples of casual sales are one-time sales of household items, children’s toys, tools, etc. at a yard sale, garage sale, or through a classified ad.

share|improve this answer
1  
Welcome to Mi Yodeya, Mr. 870! I believe the questioner was not seeking information about State tax laws, but about how these laws would affect selling his chometz. If you have any information on that, perhaps you could edit your post. I hope to see you around! –  YEZ Apr 7 at 19:15

I double checked with my LOR and besides the laws of New Jersey and New York shown in the other answers, the normal behavior throughout the country is that private one time sales are not charged sales tax. That is, when you see an ad in the paper for someone selling an item, the buyer is not charged sales tax and the seller (not being a business) does not have to fill out the sales tax forms and send the money to the government. Each state has its own specific laws (as we see in the other answers) but the general rule in the United States is that sales tax does not apply to this kind of sale.

Note that my LOR is not saying this as a lawyer, but as someone who is familiar with the practice of how rabbis in the United States sell chametz to nonJews for Pesach and buy them back afterwards. If the government changed the laws to force people to pay sales tax on the individual items that they sell via classified ads or yard sales, then the problems would encompass many more people. In any case, the payment or nonpayment of a tax to the government for private sales of this type would not invalidate the sale (halachically), which is the point of the original question.

share|improve this answer
    
Is your LOR also a US lawyer? –  Double AA Apr 8 at 14:43

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.