Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This may be more a semantic question than anything else, but I'm wondering what the position is on using the word "Jew" to refer to Israelites before the Assyrian captivity. My impression is that the term "Jew"/"Yehudi" is used today because the descendants of the Kingdom of Judah are all that remain after the destruction of the Kingdom of Israel by the Assyrians, but does it retroactively apply to earlier Israelites who were not of the kingdom or tribe of Judah? For example, I'll often see people refer to Moses as a Jew, but if you had asked Moses if he was a Yehudi, he would have said no, right? So, rather than asking a direct semantic question to this forum, let me ask: Are there any rabbinic sources that refer to the Children of Israel before the Assyrian captivity as Jews? If not, what terms did the sages use to describe the people of that era?

share|improve this question
    
Semantic... or Semitic? :D –  Avram Levitt Mar 27 at 2:52
1  
while one cannot answer "is it OK" the basics of this have been dealt with here judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/14630/… and in linked questions –  Danno Mar 27 at 2:55
    
Jew was first used in its singular form in the Book of Esther. So I'm not sure if there was any concept of a "Jew" for a very long time. A midrash says that Mordechai was called a Jew to separate him from those hellenized/idolatrous Hebrews that existed in the Land of Israel. –  rosenjcb Mar 27 at 3:39
    
@rosenjcb Zechariah 8:23 –  Double AA Mar 27 at 21:14
    
It's used as an adjective there, and not as a noun though. –  rosenjcb Mar 27 at 22:22

1 Answer 1

The following is taken from the encyclopedia אוצר ישראל Vol. 5 by R. Eisenstein:

In the beginning "Jews" were known as עברים - Hebrews, named for אברם העברי - “Avram the Hebrew” (Bereishis 14:13) who came מעבר (from the other side) of the River Euphrates. And so too Yosef was referred to as “a Hebrew youth” (Bereishis 41:12), and Jonah the Prophet said “I am a Hebrew” (Yonah 1:9), and it says “And the Philistines said: Behold the Hebrews are coming out of the holes in which they hid themselves” (Shmuel Ⅰ 14:11).

The sons/tribes of Yaakov/Yisrael and their descendants were called בני ישראל - the Children of Israel. And after the Bnei Ephraim who were the ten tribes separated from the kingdom of the House of David in the days of Rechav’am ben Shlomo, and only the Bnei Yehudah and the Bnei Binyamin remained under his rule, the were called יהודים after the tribe of Yehudah who were the main group, and after the name of the land ארץ יהודה (the Land of Yehudah) in which they dwelt. And just as the offspring of Ephraim were called אפרתי, so too were the offspring of Yehudah called יהודי. And after the exile of the ten tribes only the descendants of Yehudah and Binyamin remained in Eretz Yisrael, and they were called יהודים and their language was called יהודית as in Yeshayahu 36:11. And even after they too were exiled they were thus called.

Mordechai who was from the tribe of Binyamin was also called “איש יהודי” (Esther 2:5). In the writings of Chazal, the name Yehudi denotes not just a person’s Jewish roots, but also a person who only believes in the God of Israel, and R. Yochanan taught: Really, Mordechai came from Binyamin, so why did they call him Yehudi? Because he repudiated idol worship, because anyone who repudiates idol worship is called a Yehudi (Megillah 13a). The same gemara also comments on the posuk “And his wife the Yehudiah gave birth to Yered” (Divrei Hayomim Ⅰ 4:18) - why is she called Yehudiah, surely her name was Bisyah? Because she denied idol worship.

However, in the Gemara and Midrashim Jews are still called by their old name ישראל or בן/בת ישראל, and only if the quote from foreign sources do they mention the name Yehudi. In the Gemara all customs which are to do with modest behavior which the daughters of Israel were accustomed in, even though they are not explicitly written in the Torah, are called דת יהודית (Kesuvos 72a).

The word "Yehudi" was in former times was considered a term of insult when used by non-Jews, and therefore if they did not wish to insult a Jew they would call him a Hebrew or Israelite. Even now the name Zhid/Yid or Jude or Jew is considered an insulting term in many countries, but Jews in the enlightened countries try to make the name Jew a pleasant term, and many of the sages of the Jews use this name in reference to themselves.

Those who write about the history of the Jews use the term "Hebrew" up until the time of Yaakov, and the name "Yisrael" from the time of the twelve tribes until the destruction of the first temple, and from then on they use the name "Jew".

share|improve this answer
    
Is this the original or your translation? –  Double AA Mar 27 at 21:14

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.