Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I need some help finding sources for great people who left out the second half of bentching (i.e. everything from the harachamans and on, after the four blessings). Most people seem to have the custom to say that part, and that custom must have been around for a long time because the Tur (Orach Chayim 189) defends this practice, but I have heard that Rav Chaim Soloveitchik and the Vilna Gaon did not say that part. However, I have never seen sources discussing the practice of either of these two rabbis and was wondering if anyone could provide such sources, or sources discussing the practice of any other great people who did not say the second half of bentching.

share|improve this question
Ever? I can give you some who did not say it on Shabbos. – Y ez Mar 19 '14 at 21:32
The Pathway to Prayer Bentcher does mention one, but I don't have it on me now. The last part of bentching isn't obligaory (Tur 189, Aruch Hashulchan 189:7), so it wouldn't surprise me if some great rabbis decided not to say it. – Matt Mar 19 '14 at 21:39
Before you start asking about people who don't say it, can you give any reason why anyone should say it? – Double AA Mar 19 '14 at 22:13
@DoubleAA Minhag isn't reason enough? After all, it is in every siddur/bentcher I've ever seen. – Matt Mar 19 '14 at 23:54
@Matt So add that information to the question! – Double AA Mar 20 '14 at 0:17

According to סידור הגר"א בנגלה ובנסתר the Vilna Gaon only omitted those verses on Shabbath.

In the 1971 edition, section one, page קנט includes them.

In section three, נוסח התפילות והברכות לדעת הגר"א, note 90, it says:

בברהמ"ז לא היה הגר"א אומר בשבת רק עד הרחמן הוא יפרנסנו בכבוד ולא עד בכלל ולא יותר.

On that note, there is a footnote 116, which says this is according to eyewitness accounts of his students.

share|improve this answer
Why only on shabbat? Was it to avoid praying for personal needs? – Yitzchak Mar 20 '14 at 14:19
You'll have to ask him or his students. Or you can ask the question on this great website I found! – Seth J Mar 20 '14 at 14:26
Heh. I was asking your opinion more than anything. I plan on asking a more general question about praying for personal needs on shabbat after I look at the sugya. – Yitzchak Mar 20 '14 at 14:33
I'm not entirely sure, but I believe it did mention that somewhere along the way. I'll try to remember to check again. – Seth J Mar 20 '14 at 14:47

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.