Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I was web-searching earlier when I came across this: http://kesher-tefillin.com/. This discusses a programme in which students make their own tefillin peshutim. I saw that they had a link for haskamot, however, when I visited it, I saw that you need to email them to get them. Does anyone know if this is actually kosher, who gives their hashgachot, and who gives them their haskamot?

share|improve this question
    
How about we ask him to send us his references, which are available upon request? kesher-tefillin.com/RabbinicalApproval.html –  Clint Eastwood Feb 26 at 18:33
add comment

2 Answers 2

Per Kesher Tefilins website

My semi-original design has the halachic approval of Rabbi Nissim Karelitz and his rabbinic court. Rabbi Karelitz is one of the pre-eminent rabbis and halachic decisors of this generation; In addition, the official rabbinical authority over the "Kesher Tefillin" project (as I am calling it) is Rabbi Saul Berman, a very prominent American Orthodox rabbi.

share|improve this answer
    
I guess I looked at the wrong part of the website, although I would like to see our tefillin mumchim answer before I choose an answer, as the whole thing seemed a bit suspect to me. –  Noach mi Frankfurt Feb 26 at 16:21
add comment

First of all, not everyone is in a position to spend ~$1000 or more on a pair of tefilin nor does everyone understand why they would want to do so and many people would write tefilin off (no pun intended) as out of their price range if they thought that was the price range. Anyone keeping genuinely kosher peshutim in the market is, IMHO, doing a very good thing. That being said, one thing seems suspect to me.

He bills this as a pre- Bar Mitzvah project. Having people under bar mitzvah make tefilin enters into controversial territory. While RaMBaM holds that anyone can make the leather for battim because untouched rawhide would be just as good, and any ibbud is therefore not essential, others including the mechaber disagree (O"C 32). Furthermore, the kids are not making the leather, they are folding the parchment into battim, inserting the parshiyos, and sewing them up, all of which are essential so RaMBaM's argument would not apply. I recall a section in the Keset which touches on what pesulim can and can't do but I'm pretty sure inserting parshiyos and sewing battim is on the can't list (given that a qualified sofer is supposed to know Keset by heart, I should definitely start another chazara).

share|improve this answer
    
The first thing that really got me suspicious was that he embossed the shins, something which I have heard is not kosher, according to most authorities. Also, the lack of haskamot on the page devoted to such seemed highly suspicious to me. –  Noach mi Frankfurt Feb 26 at 17:57
    
Where did you see embossed shins? –  Yitzchak Feb 26 at 18:00
    
He goes through his process online and mentions that he has a special hand press for embossing shins. –  Noach mi Frankfurt Feb 26 at 19:10
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.