Sign up ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Rambam says that one who does not believe even one of the 13 principles of faith does not get into Olam HaBa.

Here is my question: The same Rambam spoke about the concept of a Tinok shenishba bein hanachrim; supposedly this person is forgiven for not following the halacha. Supposing that person knows a lot of Jewish opinions (including Karaite and Christian opinions) and a lot about Torah, etc. and keeps studying them, but they continue to sin because it's convenient to remain as they are and they don't have enough evidence to change there whole lifestyle. Is there a chance they have stopped having the status of Tinok shenishba bein hanachrim? Do they still get forgive and admitted into Olam HaBa?

share|improve this question
why did you remove even more from this question than from the other one? the other question had the other paragraphs. Can we then keep the first sentence about the rambam, and the contents of the question as you left it last time? – Gregory Magarshak Feb 6 '14 at 19:05
This question is not about you! It's about if a tinok shenishba can lose his status by studying torah. – Double AA Feb 6 '14 at 19:08
For example if there is a basis to consider that it is better for the tinoq shenishba to stop learning before they a) stop being a tinoq shenishba, and b) might become an apikoros or kofer, if their emunah is not increasing from the learning. The information I am seeking is what happens in the afterlife to those people? For example are they held responsible if someone else loses their faith or is on a lower level now because of their public debating and activities? etc. – Gregory Magarshak Feb 6 '14 at 19:19
If we leave the question as it is, with these comments, I think there is enough information here to get answers focused on this particular issue. What happens in the afterlife to the people who progress in this manner through learning Torah and continue to publicly say what they really think, possibly affecting other people? – Gregory Magarshak Feb 6 '14 at 19:20
@GregoryMagarshak hi and a belated welcome to Mi Yodeya. I think it would be better to roll back to revision 2 on this question. While of course many questions are asked out of some personal need, we really aim for broader applicability here -- we're asking and answering not just for you but for the whole Internet for years to come. So a question about a person in such-and-such situation works better than one that's about you in particular. Does that make sense? We of course hope that answers to the depersonalized question will also help you; this way they help others too. – Monica Cellio Feb 6 '14 at 19:25

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.