Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Bavli, Shabas 10 amud 2, has (in my own translation):

And Rava b. Machseya said R. Chama b. Guria said Rav said, "One who gives a gift to his friend must inform him.…"

Raban Shim'on b. Gamliel said, "One who gives bread to a child must inform his mother." What should he do to him? Abaye said, "Spread oil on him and apply eyeshadow to him."

Rashi explains that the oil and eyeshadow are "so his mother will ask him 'who did this?' and the child will tell her 'so-and-so did it, and he also gave me bread'".

Rashi explains, too, why this rule exists altogether, why we must inform our recipients:

must inform him: "I'll give you such-and-such gift". This is a honorable way: for he may be embarrassed to accept it, but because of the [advance warning] he will be appeased by words and not embarrassed about the matter. Similarly, if it were given in his home without his knowledge, one must inform him that it came to him by his hand, because then he will be his friend [literally: lover].

Only the second of those reasons applies to someone who's given bread to a child. So one is dabbing oil on the child in order that his mother will be the giver's friend; note that the giver of the bread is identified as male throughout (by use of masculine verbs, etc.). How do we explain this g'mara in light of the idea[1] that a man should not be trying to make friends with another's wife? (Most mothers of children are married.)

[1] Citation needed.

share|improve this question
up vote 4 down vote accepted

In the same sugya in the gemara Beitzah 16a, Rashi explains:

"He should inform his mother" - he should make for him (the child) a sign so that if he eats it (the food) before he comes to his mother, she will see the sign and ask him "Who did this to you?", and he will answer "It was so-and-so, and he also gave me some bread", and through this his father and mother will know that he (so-and-so) loves them, and cause an increase in love and friendship in Yisrael.

share|improve this answer

To be tight buddies, no; to treat as another human being, yes. Recall that the angels, according to the medrish, asked Sara how her husband was doing too.

share|improve this answer
To treat as another human, sure, but that doesn't seem to be what Rashi is saying, and wouldn't seem to necessitate informing her who her benefactor is. – msh210 Jan 14 '14 at 18:22

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.