Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I heard recently the following:

Someone who desecrates the Shabbos in a non-Orthodox or non-Jewish neighborhood doesn't have the classification of a "m'chalel Shabbos b'farhesia" (someone who desecrates the Shabbos in an open, public fashion.)

Are there any achronim/poskim that said this or that speak about this (one way or the other.)

share|improve this question

The Kitzur Shulchan Aruch in 72:2 writes that in order to be considered a m'chalel Shabbos b'farhesia the person will have desecrated Shabbat in the presence of 10 Jews - but they don't need to actually see him doing the sin - they just need to know about it.

ופרהסיא הוי בפני עשרה מישראל. ולאו דוקא שעושה בפניהם ממש, אלא שיודעין מהעברה - ש"ך סי' קנ"ז סעיף קטן ד', דהכי מוכח בש"ס ופוסקים, גבי והא אסתר פרהסיא הוה. וכן כתב הפרי- מגדים

So a person who desecrates Shabbat in a location where there aren't any Jews - and he doesn't publicize his actions (nor do his FaceBook friends) - would not be classified as a m'chalel Shabbos b'farhesia, and when he touches wine it would not become Yayin Nesech, etc.

Regarding being seen by non-frum Jews.

A non-frum Jew is still a Jew; he is obliged to keep all the Mitzvot (and will be held accountable for every minor detail he didn't keep) and desecrating Shabbat in his presence shows a disdain to Hashem, his Mitzvot and his Shabbat.

Unless the non-frum Jew himself purposely desecrates Shabbat publicly - in which case he get the classification of an idol worshiper, as the Rambam says at the end of Hilchot Shabbat:

השבת ועבודה זרה--כל אחת משתיהן, שקולה כנגד שאר כל מצוות התורה; והשבת היא האות שבין הקדוש ברוך הוא ובינינו, לעולם. לפיכך כל העובר על שאר המצוות, הרי הוא בכלל רשעי ישראל; אבל מחלל שבת בפרהסיה, הרי הוא כעובד עבודה זרה--ושניהם כגויים, לכל דבריהם.‏

share|improve this answer
Classifying him as a idol worshiper is a chumra (he takes on the dinim f a non-jew) yet in this case you are using it as a koola since someone who is "m'chalel Shabbos" in front of them will not get the status of "m'chalel Shabbos b'farhesia". – eramm Dec 31 '13 at 14:08
Is the analysis of the status of not frum Jews in this regard your own? – Double AA Dec 31 '13 at 15:18
@eramm the quoted Rambam says "לכל דבריהם". (I haven't checked nos'e kelim or other works.) – msh210 Jan 1 '14 at 6:44
@msh210 this is meant to be a chumra i.e. his wine is yayin nesach his food is bishul akum etc.... it does not remove his status of a Jew. – eramm Jan 1 '14 at 15:12
@Danny are there non-frum Jews in this day and age who are not considered "tinok sh'nishba" thus perhaps they can't be ruled as a person who brazenly is mechalel shabbos ? – eramm Jan 1 '14 at 15:14

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.