Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Genesis 18:8 (JPS):

And he took curd, and milk, and the calf which he had dressed, and set it before them; and he stood by them under the tree, and they did eat.

Looks like Abraham and 3 mysterious visitors don't mind eating mixed milk and calf. If Jews don't eat cheeseburgers, why did Abraham serve a calf with milk?

share|improve this question
    
Duplicate? judaism.stackexchange.com/q/4078 –  msh210 Dec 31 '13 at 6:52
    
@msh210 I believe so. "Avraham serving milk/meat together" is a specific example of that question. –  Double AA Dec 31 '13 at 7:00
    
possible duplicate of Avot keeping Mitzvot –  Shmuel Brin Dec 31 '13 at 7:18
1  
Not every question that overlaps is a duplicate. There are opinions which would qualify as an answer to the "duplicate" question that would leave this one unanswered. –  Yirmeyahu Dec 31 '13 at 7:55
1  
@ShmuelBrin, Conversely, if you were to merge these two questions the answer I have given here would be entirely irrelevant to the "duplicate" question. –  Yirmeyahu Dec 31 '13 at 8:10

4 Answers 4

I do not have the precise location but I was taught that the Yalkut Yoseph brings down eight answers/considerations to this question. Here are some highlights:

According to Rashi the milk was served first which is entirely permissable. According to the Maharal, Avraham only fulfilled the positive commandments while the Gra brings opinions that he wasn't particular regarding Rabbinic commandments (there is no indication the meat and dairy where cooked together which would constitute a Torah prohibition). And regardless of his own observance, the Shita Mekubetzus points out he thought they were b'nei Noach [non-Jews who are not obligated to separate meat and dairy].

Of course this was before the Torah was given so the question doesn't really begin if one takes a minimalist approach to the question of whether the Avos kept the mitzvos.

share|improve this answer
    
I have edited to clarify the relevance of being b'nei Noach but I feel that to elaborate upon the nature of positive vs. negative commands or the nature of a rabbinic commandment is to go down the rabbit trail of answering entirely different questions. I would be interested in knowing what is generally felt about this issue. –  Yirmeyahu Dec 31 '13 at 7:51
    
Rashi does not imply that the milk was separate from the meat. If anything, Rashi sounds the opposite - Rashi says that each thing was brought out as soon as it was ready. That would imply that he specifically did not wait until they finished one thing to bring out the next. –  YeZ Jan 27 at 18:58
    
Milk and curds could have been ready immediately, but a calf would take more than 30 minutes to dress and cook. If you think like Rashi that each thing was brought as it was ready, the milk and curds could have been finished before the meat ever arrived. –  Mike Jan 28 at 0:12

The Malbim explains that he created a calf using Sefer Yetzirah which can be eaten with milk.

http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=40102&st=&pgnum=168

share|improve this answer
    
Why can it be eaten with milk? –  Double AA Jan 23 at 17:53
    
I am no expert in Sefer Yetzirah but I will take the Malbims word for it,also the Shla talks about the eiver min hachai by the Shevatim who used sefer Yetzirah and the issur does not apply by such an animal –  sam Jan 23 at 18:16
    
Followup question: judaism.stackexchange.com/q/34932 –  msh210 Jan 24 at 8:52

The Ramban understands that Avraham knew they were angels (Ramban 18:3 s.v. אד-ני אם). If so, this would make it OK to serve them milk and meat. This would also explain why he was OK serving milk and meat but not serving something impure (see Rashi about not serving the dough) because angels are holy (refered to as kedoshim) and holiness is incompatible with impurity (impurity cannot be brought into holy places).

share|improve this answer

Look at the order -- first milk, then meat. One can have milk, wash out his mouth, wait a period of time (discussed in poskim) and have meat. Which is what some are noheg for Shavuot when dairy is served and then meat.

share|improve this answer
1  
One can also have meat, wash out his mouth, wait a period of time (discussed in poskim) and have milk. –  Double AA Jan 27 at 16:37
    
Waiting 30 min. after milk is not the same as waiting 6 hours after meat (normative practice). –  user4751 Jan 27 at 18:14
    
@user4751 The 30 minute wait is not so implied in the verse, nor is any wait. Rashi implies that they specifically did not wait - He says that Avraham brought out each item as soon as it was ready. –  YeZ Jan 27 at 19:00
    
@user4751 What do you mean "normative practice"? Plenty of communities wait 1/3/4/5/5.5 hours after meat, and any waiting after milk is not at all universally practiced –  Double AA Jan 27 at 20:18

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.