Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This source claims that there is a Chovas Halevavos that quotes the Islamic Hadith without attribution. I was wondering if there are other examples of this in Jewish texts.

share|improve this question
    
If it's without attribution, how would we know? I think this is unanswerable as is. Maybe ask on History? –  msh210 Nov 25 '13 at 0:01
    
@msh210 It might have been noticed by others. Jewish scholarship sounds like a good place to look for such notes. –  Double AA Nov 25 '13 at 0:34
1  
By the way, you can always ask the proprietor of "On the Main Line" for the reference to the alleged Chovos HaL'vavos quote. –  Fred Nov 25 '13 at 1:13
1  
From the article: ***Pg. 643 of the Rosh Hashana machzor cites the Chovos Ha-levavos' citation of the famous distinction between the lesser jihad (war) and the greater jihad (internal war with oneself). –  Menachem Nov 25 '13 at 2:26
1  
Ohr Chaim on Devarim 20:1: כי תצא למלחמה וגו'. אולי שרמז הכתוב מלמחת אדם עם יצרו ובא להסיר מלבבך מורך ואמר כי תצא למלחמה הידוע' שאין גדולה ממנה –  Ephraim Nov 25 '13 at 9:25

2 Answers 2

I do not have any specific citations but according to Rabbi Lamm in Torah uMadda:

In the Geonic period, according to the eleventh-century R. Joseph Ibn Aknin (in his commentary to the Song of Songs), R. Hai Gaon (939-1038), 'the last and greatest of the Geonim,' did not hesitate to use Arabic sources, including Arabic love songs, to prove a Talmudic point; in addition, he quotes the Koran and Hadith (the sayings and doings of Muhammed). (page 22).

share|improve this answer
    
Does anyone know where to find this commentary to Canticles by R Aknin? –  Double AA Nov 25 '13 at 17:12

In rabbinic sources after the rise of Islam? Certainly, there was a cross-pollination of ideas. It may not be that a given rabbi was reading the Hadith per se, it may have been that they heard something from someone and said "wow, that's powerful." They may have known it was recorded as Hadith; or that it was loosely based on Islamic thought; or not at all. The "non-attribution" thing isn't such a big deal; there were points in time when the scholarly style was "I will say my thing, and you can figure out for yourself what sources this is drawing on." (Rabbi Pelkovitz points this out about the Sforno.)

Here's a blog on the quotation found in both Chovot HaLevavot (and then later rabbinic sources) and the Hadith about a victorious army returning home -- "you've won the easy war; now comes the hard war [i.e. how to live in peacetime with justice and a sense of purpose]." He quotes material about the noted overlap between Chovot HaLevavot and the Hadith.

Similarly, there have been rabbis who were unimpressed by scholars who could quote a great number of sources but couldn't think critically about them. The description used was -- "it's like a donkey carrying a giant load of books." It's said this colorful put-down also originated in Islamic thought.

Look, the Talmud says (Sanhedrin 38b) that the sage Rabbi Meir (who lived around the year 100) would teach Proverbs with all sorts of stories about foxes. Doesn't that sound like somebody else? That's okay!

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.