Based on this question and the ensuant discussion, I would like to know if a person makes a blessing upon anointing himself for pleasure. If not, why not?
- Anybody can ask a question
- Anybody can answer
- The best answers are voted up and rise to the top
Rabbbi Michael Taubes in a YU shiur “Berachot on Worldly Pleasures” quotes the Ramban (Chidushei HaRamban to Berachot Chapter 8, s.v. nireh li) who writes that the benefit has to be from something which enters into the body; this is why no berachah, he says, is recited over things like a cool, refreshing shower, a nice hot bath or a pleasant breeze, even though one certainly enjoys these things.
I imagine that oil for anointing is not considered to “enter the body” and that is why no blessing is recited.
(Please read the shiur. The blessing on the light of a fire, which hopefully does not enter the body, is only because of motzoei shabbos or yom kippur.)
same reason you dont make a blessing on a hot shower. not all pleasure/benefit has a bracha.
if it were otherwise, it would appear in the mishna/talmud.