Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

What is the punishment for receiving a seruv from a Bais Din for litigating B'Arkoas (in non-Jewish courts) without a heter?

share|improve this question
1  
The punishment wouldn't be for the siruv. It would be for going to Arkaos which is like "lifting his hand against the Torah of Moshe" –  Shmuel Brin Oct 22 '13 at 2:46

2 Answers 2

A search found the following on the consequences of a shtar siruv:

1) Rabbinical Council of America “Jun 1, 1993 -- RESOLUTION: MATTER OF PRE-NUPTIAL AGREEMENTS & RECALCITRANT SPOUSES”

Resolved, that any person against whom there is an outstanding Shetar Siruv, issued by a Beit Din consisting of three Orthodox Rabbis, in regard to matters of issuance or receipt of a Get: 1. Shall not be permitted to occupy any elective or appointed position, or position as employee, within the Synagogue organization or within any of its affiliates. 2. Shall be excluded from membership in the Synagogue or in any of its affiliates. 3. Shall not be called to the Torah nor be given any other liturgical honor on any occasion.

Further, that such person who reside within our community: 4. Shall have his or her name announced on a regular monthly basis at the conclusion of Sabbath services. 5. Shall have his or her name published in the Synagogue bulletin with a call to the membership to limit their social and economic relations to such persons.

2) Rabbinical Court of Greater Cleveland Feb 2005. The named person is subject to the strictures of Yoreh Deah 334 (2).

3) Beth Din of America

A summoning beth din may issue a “seruv,” or a contempt order. A seruv is simply a public declaration by a beth din that someone was summoned to beth din but refused to meet their obligation under Jewish law to appear in front of the beth din. Sometimes, Jewish communities or synagogues impose sanctions on such people, such as not giving them aliyos (being called up to the reading of the Torah) or refraining from social interaction, to pressure the person to meet their obligation. The beth din is not necessarily involved at that point – the community or synagogue decides what measures are appropriate.

I did not find how these were applied practically.

share|improve this answer
    
At least item 1 is irrelevant, as it discusses what was done "in regard to matters of issuance or receipt of a Get" whereas the question asks about someone "litigating B'Arkoas (in non-Jewish courts) without a heter". +1, though, for item 3. –  msh210 Oct 22 '13 at 18:05
    
@msh210 Your comment accepted. It implies that there may be different standards for a shtar seruv depending on the circumstances under which it was issued. –  Avrohom Yitzchok Oct 23 '13 at 15:40

Are you asking how G-d punishes it? I don't know.

As far as what we can do today, today's batei din don't have the power of corporeal punishment. (Israel is a bit more complicated, let's assume we're talking elsewhere.) Depending on the language of the seruv, the rabbis could call on the Jewish community to shun the individual; deny him any honors in synagogue; or potentially even bar his entrance to synagogue altogether. Shulchan Aruch discusses different levels of bans, some of which would mean the individual can't even count for a minyan. Rabbenu Tam is famous for describing an agreement that no one in the Jewish community would do business with someone found in contempt; my understanding is this is rarely used today (but I heard Rabbi Hershel Schachter state it might be necessary to bring it back).

In short, it can vary, and it only works based on how people in the local community agree to abide by it. If the fellow under contempt walks away from the community altogether, well we live in a liberal society and there's little we can do. (Though we could still assemble peaceful protests on public land outside the guy's house, for instance.)

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.