Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

The Alshich on Ki Tetze teaches that until the age of 13 a person has only an evil inclination. The good inclination comes only at Bar Mitzva. Hence, the yetzer hara is likened to an old seasoned warrior (who has total control of the body before the yetzer tov comes), while the yetzer tov is likened to a young lad. (See there.)

The Alshich continues to say that for the yetzer tov to conquer the yetzer hara is a formidable task, and is the "tachlis hagevura" (the ultimate mightiness).

Why did God make a system like this? For free will to be balanced it seems logical that both should exist simultaneously and neither should have any advantage over the other.

share|improve this question
2  
I thought the source for this is from earlier, I'm thinking the Chazalic era. –  Adam Mosheh Jul 17 '13 at 21:57
    
Ecclesiastes 4:13 better a Poor wise youth than an old foolish king. I assume that's where it's coming from, in different words. –  user3114 Sep 15 '13 at 15:08

2 Answers 2

note: source is in kabbalah alot earlier then the alshich

true, it is unbalanced in that sense. but there are many many things to say about this issue, here are some pointers:

we (at least its in my machzor) say on rosh hashana "ata yodeah yitzram ve'atah (possibly "ki" ) yotzram"(אתה יודע יצרם ואתה יוצרם) meaning god created us with a disadvantage and therefore understands our wrongdoing's = its a defense ("pischon peh") for us (why he wants us with more evil inspires why create evil and alot of philosophy )

and you made a crucial misquote the yh is called "melech zaken uksil " and the yetzer tov "naar miskain chacham" the yt is smarter the the yh they both have advantages and disadvantages strengh and weakness one who is misgaber yt more is considered a smarter more refined person by society

and thirdly (building on #2) the yh has the strength of being easier thats why anyone would do anything bad (e.g. steal lie ) and yt makes life more difficult "its hard to do the right thing"

i hope that you find this helpful

share|improve this answer

The yetzer hara has a connotation of being the animal instinct, the inclination to give in to our base desires — not just "evil" with its implications of willful intentional malice. It's almost better to read it as "the naughty inclination".

If you take the "animal instinct" connotation it makes much more sense to see children as being dominated by yetzer hara and learning to allow yetzer tov to take over. Cognitivtely we know that young people's brains don't fully develop what are called "executive functions" like risk assessment, planning, problem solving, attention / focus until late adolescence and early 20s. These are the skills that let you not hit someone when they take your cookie, for example.

As Rabbi Lawrence Kushner says, you can't control how you feel but you can control how you act. Learning self-control takes years of training and just growing up. Little kids don't have much ability to thoughtfully control their actions over their instincts.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.