Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

What is to be done with a Sefer Torah written by an apikoreis, or by a soffer of unknown apikoreis-status (whether it be a question of the status of the soffer who wrote it, or if it is unknown who the soffer actually was)?

To elaborate: Is there an issue with burying it and if so what is / might be the issue? Also, in cases of doubt, is there any argument to allow the Sefer to be used for anything (e.g., to be lained from, to dance with on Simchas Torah)?

share|improve this question

Rambam Laws of Tefilin, Mezuzah, and Sefer Torah 1:13:

יג ספר תורה תפילין ומזוזות שכתבן מין, יישרפו. כתבן גוי, או ישראל משומד, או מוסר, או עבד, או אישה, או קטן--הרי אלו פסולין וייגנזו: שנאמר "וקשרתם . . . וכתבתם" (דברים ו,ח-ט; דברים יא,יח-כ)--כל שמוזהר על הקשירה ומאמין בה, הוא שכותב. נמצאו ביד מין ואין ידוע מי כתבן, ייגנזו; נמצאו ביד גוי, כשרים. ואין לוקחין ספרים תפילין ומזוזות מן הגויים ביתר על דמיהן, שלא להרגיל אותם לגונבם ולגוזלם.‏

A Torah scroll, Tefillin, or Mezuzah written by a heretic -- burn it!... If you find one in the possession of a heretic and don't know who wrote it, bury it; if in the possession of a non-Jew, assume it's kosher.

The question comes up with missionary Bibles -- there's a recent Rabbi Hershel Schachter mp3 where he says you can throw the whole thing out.

If you don't know whether the author was a heretic (he got a "D" in Heresy 101?) ... eh, ask a rabbi in each situation. Rabbi Moshe Feinstein addressed the question of how to approach music written by a man who had many vices -- Rav Moshe clarified he was still not deemed a "heretic."

Rabbi Shneur Lyman (in Tradition 2008) has a great piece concerning a letter from Rabbi Azriel Hildesheimer to someone cleaning out some old books -- he says "the one written by that fellow Frenkel who left the faith? Burn it, whatever!" Someone had mistaken this for Rabbi Zechariah Frankel , who had some ideas that would today be seen as on the borderline between Orthodox and Conservative. It turns out the letter concerned a fellow named Frenkel who had actually converted to Christianity and encouraged others to do the same.

share|improve this answer
Just reading about the author of shmiras shabbos k'hilchoso who has recently died. His father, Rabbi Neuwirth in Germany was at a sefer torah completion where they invited the local reform rabbi to also write one of the last letters. He called out, that that, would make the sefer torah posul. – user2800 Jun 23 '13 at 1:05
@Annex not surprising. RMF has a discussion about calling someone for an aliyah if they ascribe no sanctity to the text being read. – Shalom Jun 23 '13 at 4:44

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.